AI majors promise not to steal – Indonesia may legislate content protection – New poll suggests streaming might be overpriced

(AI illustration)

November 15, 2026

We reported last week that Meta temporarily backed away from its self declared entitlement to all online content belonging to its business customers for the purposes of ingesting AI training data.

Possibly the other AI majors concluded it was the right time to claim the high ground. Anthropic, OpenAI, Google and Microsoft have issued statements saying they will honour a common “robot.txt” instruction from online publishers that denies permission to AI web crawlers from scraping publisher data for Large Language Model training.

It’s a positive signal. The AI majors must sense their vulnerability to judicial and legislative intervention.

However.

Only Anthropic has implemented its commitment. The others say it’s coming soon.

None of the AI companies are disgorging or acknowledging the training data they have already scraped.

Even the most recent commitments are voluntary. As yet, they have no force in regulatory law or licensing agreements.

***

The front-of-mind public battle between the AI majors and media publishers over intellectual property certainly appears to be a new chapter in a fight that began over hyperlinks on Google Search and Facebook.

At the risk of encouraging fatalism, I noted that Meta Canada’s Rachel Curran was publicly speculating that the Carney government is about to cave (not her term) on the Online News Act in order to readmit Canadian news organizations and their content to Meta platforms.

Another dangling comment came from culture & identity minister Marc Miller who cast shade on the Online News Act in an interview with CTV’s Vassy Kapelos. Miller characterized both the ONA and the Online Streaming Act as “noble” laws but “they haven’t worked the way we hoped they would.”

Other nations appear undeterred.

After a long delay, Australia legislated its News Bargaining Incentive that enforces financial consequences for Meta if it follows through with its threat to ban domestic news in retaliation for mandatory licensing payments to news publishers.

Bigger news is breaking in Indonesia, a country of 230 million and Facebook’s third biggest market after India and the United States. According to reports, Indonesia is proposing to revise its copyright laws to require Big Tech platforms to compensate news publishers for hyperlinked news snippets as well as AI ingestion.

***

A new Angus Reid poll marks another milestone in the long decline of cable television viewership in Canada. It says 50% of Canadians subscribe to cable, down from 88% in 2012 (a year after Netflix arrived). And 84% of Canadians say they pay for at least one streaming service.

Bell Media’s Crave is in fourth place behind Amazon Prime, Netflix and Disney+.

These new figures and the downward trend in cable subscriptions won’t surprise anyone. But there are some other numbers worth noting:

  • Nothing has changed in terms of generational habits: the cable television audience is aging out.
  • Streaming subscription churn is climbing slowly and the poll attributes that to cost rather than content.
  • Nonetheless the number of streaming junkies (subscribers to 4 or more services) is on the rise.

If the pollster’s conclusion that streaming subscribers are increasingly sensitive to cost, I suggest that has implications for Mark Carney’s claim that he needed to give away Canada’s Netflix tax based on his assumption of price inelasticity, i.e. that streaming services would succeed in passing along their costs to subscribers.

Note: I can’t tell from full report, but it seems that Angus Reid surveyed individuals rather than households. That might affect the results.

***

If you would like regular notifications of future posts from MediaPolicy.ca you can follow this site by signing up under the Follow button in the bottom right corner of the home page;

or sign up for a free subscription to MediaPolicy.ca on Substack;

or follow
@howardalaw on X or Howard Law on LinkedIn.

I can be reached by e-mail at howard.law@bell.net.

This post is copyrighted by Howard Law, all rights reserved. 2026.

How Carney’s $600M culture budget compares to the CRTC Netflix tax he killed

(AI illustration)

November 9, 2026

How does Prime Minister Carney’s $600 million make-good for Canadian content compare to the money he nixed back in June, the CRTC’s $200 million cash levies on foreign video and audio streamers?

I do love a bar graph (or five). Nevertheless, these snapshots reveal only one side of the elephant (I’ll explain below).

Here is Table 1. It demonstrates the policy problem. As conventional broadcasting has declined since its peak in 2017, so have the CRTC-mandated contributions to Canadian media Funds that supplement private investment and public funding.

The Canada Media Fund finances Canadian dramas, documentaries and children’s programming.

Other TV Production Funds include corporately sponsored (e.g. Bell, Québecor or Rogers) or specialty (e.g. Indigenous and Black Screen Offices) Funds. They play a similar role to the Canada Media Fund.

Local Independent TV News pays the bills for a big portion of newsroom expenditures for Independent local TV stations such as Hamilton’s CHCH-TV and Gatineau’s CHOT-TV. It excludes national networks like CTV, TVA and City-TV but now includes Global News because it’s no longer owned by a cable company.

All Radio and Music Funds include the suite of musician development organizations (e.g. FACTOR, Starmaker and their French language compatriots) as well as the Community Radio Fund of Canada and the Indigenous Music Office.

Many of these Funds receive both support from CRTC levies and government subsidies.

(Notes 1 and 2 below correspond to Table 1).

You see the decline. But of course it’s worse when the funding data is adjusted for inflation, so here’s Table 2 which does that by restating the 2017 funding in 2025 dollars. In this table, the funding decline is more pronounced:

That’s the policy problem. What about the remedy? Table 3 was the ill-fated CRTC solution to the problem by levying an estimated $200M (in 2024 dollars) of annual contributions from Netflix, Spotify and the other streaming services:

On to the next concept. As I said, many of these CRTC-supported Funds have been historically co-financed with direct government contributions. After striking down the CRTC’s Netflix tax, Carney’s $600M make-good pot of federal money can be compared to contributions made by Canadian broadcasters in Table 4. (Notes 3,4,5)

And finally Table 5 illustrates how Carney’s $600M for the 2026/27 budget year compares to federal spending in the previous year:

Here are some notes and caveats:

(1) I sourced this data using my AI Chatbot, Perplexity. I like that product because it shows sources and conflicts in data collection. I would normally drill down into the actual sources to verify, but in this case it would be too time consuming.

There could be all sorts of problems with data or unrevealed assumptions. For example, it’s possible that “one-time” regulatory or government contributions are included in an annual figure. Reader beware.

(2) The “Viewing” data in Table 1 is a proxy for broadcaster and streamer revenue earned from subscriptions and advertising dollars. I am seeking to illustrate the criss-crossing fortunes of traditional television and streaming.

(3) We should be careful about assuming the $600M in government funding will be there again in 2027/28, let alone in five or ten years. My guess is that the government will re-evaluate the whole scheme once the CRTC has implemented Carney’s forthcoming policy direction on how much to demand from broadcasters and streamers in direct investments in Canadian content for their own platforms.

Also, the $600 million includes cultural spending that does not correspond to any CRTC levy, for example Telefilm ($68M) and the Canada History Fund ($5M). Also, the $600M includes $42M to replace CRTC-ordered cable company expenditures on television channels deemed by the Commission to be “services of exceptional importance” such as CPAC, TV5 or APTN.

(4) We should also keep in mind that although the $600M is for budget year 2026/27 it may represent more than just twelve months of funding. It is probably intended to make up for the loss of Netflix Tax contributions in both 2025/26 and 2026/27.

(5) The spectacular increase in funding for the Independent Local TV News Fund should be considered in the context that the number of local stations supported by the Fund has doubled from 17 to 35, owing to the participation of the Global News network of stations.

***

If you would like regular notifications of future posts from MediaPolicy.ca you can follow this site by signing up under the Follow button in the bottom right corner of the home page;

or sign up for a free subscription to MediaPolicy.ca on Substack;

or follow
@howardalaw on X or Howard Law on LinkedIn.

I can be reached by e-mail at howard.law@bell.net.

This post is copyrighted by Howard Law, all rights reserved. 2026.

$600 million to replace Netflix tax announced by Canadian Heritage

November 8, 2026

On a Sunday afternoon, three hours from story deadline, Heritage minister Marc Miller gave news organizations something to publish for the notoriously light Monday edition: the long awaited details of $600 million in additional cultural spending for 2026/27.

The federal money was promised in June as a make-good for Prime Minister Mark Carney’s decision to give Netflix, Spotify and other foreign streamers a break on paying cash levies to Canadian media funds.

Those Canadian media funds feed into existing public and private funding for Canadian news and entertainment programming.

The allocation of the one-time $600 million —three times the $200 million in annual streamer payments cancelled by Carney— may in fact cover more than a full fiscal year of forgiven streamer contributions that were to take effect on September 1, 2025.

The big recipients are:

  • The Canada Media Fund, financing television dramas, documentaries and children’s programming.
  • The Indigenous Screen Office, Black Screen Office, and a variety of corporate-sponsored television funds performing a similar function to the CMF.
  • Local news and community broadcasting funds including the Independent Local News Fund (i.e. not TVA, Rogers or Bell) and the Commercial Radio News Fund.
  • The Community Radio Fund.
  • “Services of exceptional importance such as CPAC, APTN and TV5.”
  • The government’s Canada Music Fund that funnels support for Canadian musicians to various industry-managed Funds, as well as the newly established Indigenous Music Office.

Three other media funds that were not tipped by the CRTC’s June 2024 levy on foreign streamers will also see cash from the government’s $600 million:

More to come.

***

If you would like regular notifications of future posts from MediaPolicy.ca you can follow this site by signing up under the Follow button in the bottom right corner of the home page;

or sign up for a free subscription to MediaPolicy.ca on Substack;

or follow
@howardalaw on X or Howard Law on LinkedIn.

I can be reached by e-mail at howard.law@bell.net.

This post is copyrighted by Howard Law, all rights reserved. 2026.

Budget 2026 strengthens news funding, cuts CBC dollars, and leaves CanCon hanging

(AI illustration)

November 7, 2026

Finance minister François-Philippe Champagne’s Budget 2026 proposes substantial cultural spending including greater support for privately owned news media.

Here is a rundown, beginning with news journalism.

The five-year federal journalist salary subsidy to news organizations introduced in 2020 has been extended yet again, to 2031/32.

The Journalism Labour Tax Credit‘s temporary bump (since 2023) from 25% to 35% of salaries is extended by Budget 2026 for two more years, to the end of calendar year 2028. The 2023 elevation of the cap on subsidized salaries to $85,000 appears to be permanent.

More journalists will qualify. As Culture & Identity minister Marc Miller announced in March, the JLTC is now available to video and audio broadcasters, effectively doubling the number of journalist positions supported by the program to 7,500. Once the 35% falls back to 25% in 2029, the government projects an annual $85M budget line. The current program cost is $75M.

Aside from the JLTC, the Carney government reshuffled the remainder of federal support targeting smaller news outlets.

The $21M annual funding for the Local Journalism Initiative is increased to $33 million for the next four years and then again to $41M in the fifth year in what the budget document describes as “ongoing” funding.

At the moment, LJI money is allocated by an industry committee and supports about 700 reporter positions at 350 news organizations. Having aggressively expanded the number of positions over several years without an increase in funding, the LJI’s salary subsidy currently floats around 40% of journalist pay instead of full salary as originally designed. Private broadcasters are not eligible for the LJI and this did not change in Budget 2026.

More money for local news, yes, but the doubling of funding for the Local Journalism Initiative is effectively offset by the reduction of $13M to the $85M Canadian Periodical Fund for magazines, digital periodicals and community newspapers and a further $14M in 2028/29. (Note: News organizations cannot collect the JLTC subsidy and the Periodical Fund in the same year).

And more reshuffling of funding, the government’s $2M reduction of its $13M annual contribution to the French language TV5, announced in the Main Parliamentary Estimates in February, remains in place.

As for CBC/Radio-Canada, the Liberal government confirmed a two-year renewal of the $150M funding increase that it campaigned on in the 2025 election as the first rung in a laddered increase to bring the public broadcaster’s Parliamentary grant more in line with European benchmarks.

From Liberal Party platform (2025)

But the government did not go further up the ladder and even failed to renew the $42M in CBC funding that the Trudeau administration introduced in 2024 as a response to the broadcaster’s plan to lay off hundreds of employees, a reduction not mentioned in its campaign document. Once Budget 2026 passes, the Parliamentary grant will be approximately $1.53 billion to cover an expanded mandate, especially more local news. That’s a 16% increase in real dollars, post-inflation, since the Trudeau Liberals were elected in 2015.

The CBC employs about a third of Canada’s 11,000 professional journalists and editorial staff.

Meanwhile, federal CanCon funding for entertainment video, music and books remains unclear.

In February, Ottawa announced a $68M cut to its $203M (in 2025/26) annual federal contribution to the Canada Media Fund. The CMF juices private and public investment in Canadian dramas, documentaries and kids’ television programming. It is co-funded with Canadian cable TV companies and it was poised—until the Carney government struck down the CRTC’s ruling last June— to get funding from Netflix and the other Californian streaming services.

It’s almost certain that minister Miller intends to give the CMF a healthy slice of the previously announced $600 million in new funding, a make good for the Prime Minister’s regulatory relief for Netflix et al. Budget 2026 did not provide any itemization of the $600M or a timetable for further announcements.

Canadian books were front of mind in Budget 2026. A national online lending library of Canadian literature is in the works at the cost of about $9 million annually to cover copyright fees for publishers and authors. As for the Canada Book Fund —which supplements Canada Council grants to underwrite Canadian-authored books— the projected $3.4 million cut to its $40M budget appears to have been replaced with a $5M increase to its annual budget.

The $16M cut to the federal government’s $40M contribution to the Canada Music Fund —-supporting Canadian musicians’ production and touring expenses— previously announced in February 2026 was cancelled when Budget 2025 received Royal Assent the following month, extending the $16M in funding for three more years.

Aside from these existing programs, the Finance minister announced an attention-grabbing budget line item: a personal income tax break for an as yet unidentified cohort of Canadian creative artists.

Dubbed the Canada Creative Credit, but perhaps better described as the starving artists’ tax deduction, the program will raise the effective threshold for tax free income combined with the Basic Personal Amount “up to $45,000 of annual qualifying net business income derived from original and creative artistic works.” The tax saving might be as much as $4,000 for each artist. The Finance minister did not offer a price tag for the tax expenditure.

The special tax status for artists is similar to programs in Ireland, France and the province of Québec.

The Liberals did not campaign on this item in 2025 and no public consultation was held so the shape of the program is unclear. Details were promised for the spring of 2027. One thing to watch is whether the program will apply to the growing ranks of YouTubers and online influencers who create original content and what kind of media content is contemplated. Freelance writers and photographers are another potential category of creators. The income tax relief was one of several policy proposals put forward by Richard Stursberg for Canadian book publishing in his recent book Lament for a Literature.

Caveat emptor readers, I expect I have will have some corrections or revisions to this post. The ministry of Finance did not respond by my deadline to a series of requested clarifications.

***

One of the big things left hanging by Budget 2026 is how and when the $600M in promised cultural funding, linked by minister Miller to cancelling streamer levies, will be allocated. Budget 2026 only made reference to a single year of this special funding although Miller has told reporters it is intended to be permanent.

In any event, two weeks ago I listed the top items on the Carney government’s To Do list for media funding. Here’s a reminder:

  • The federal budget clarifies when and how the $600 million in cultural spending is to be allocated.
  • That includes the fate of the apparent spending cuts for the CBC, the Canada Media Fund, the Canada Book Fund, Canada Music Fund, Canadian Periodical Fund, and the French language TV5.
  • The government is then cleared to publish its policy direction to the CRTC on what it wants to see in terms of streamer contributions to Canadian content. The CRTC will have to decide whether to hold another round of lengthy public hearings and written submissions or to cut to the chase and simply rewrite the rulings that the Carney government appears to have vacated.
  • The government will also have the opportunity to publish its revised policy governing the structure and mandate of federal video production tax credits, the Canada Media Fund, Telefilm, and the National Film Board.

***

In late October I told you about Meta’s latest content grab where it claimed the right to ingest the full editorial archive of any news organization using its AI products, even if the content was not posted to Meta platforms.

CEO Mark Zuckerberg has now backed down, at least temporarily, by announcing a “pause” on its unilateral change to terms and conditions for business accounts.

***

If you would like regular notifications of future posts from MediaPolicy.ca you can follow this site by signing up under the Follow button in the bottom right corner of the home page;

or sign up for a free subscription to MediaPolicy.ca on Substack;

or follow
@howardalaw on X or Howard Law on LinkedIn.

I can be reached by e-mail at howard.law@bell.net.

This post is copyrighted by Howard Law, all rights reserved. 2026.

Ottawa green lights next steps for porn blocking Bill S-209 – Incoming PQ Premier doubles down on streaming regs – Dirge for my favourite media commentary

(AI illustration)

November 1, 2026

Sénatrice Julie Miville-Deschênes’ Bill S-209, a proposal to age-gate online porn, must be the Parliamentary cat endowed with nine lives.

Or as Michael Geist, who opposes An Act to restrict young persons’ online access to pornographic material, describes it: “the age verification bill that won’t die.” True enough, the Senator’s bill has survived three dissolutions of Parliament over six years.

Last week Liberal backbencher Louis Villeneuve successfully moved the adoption of S-209 at second reading in the House of Commons, reversing years of the Liberal government’s steadfast refusal to support it.

After the bill passed the Senate in February, it was sponsored in the House by Conservative MP Rosemarie Falk.

The bill first tabled by Miville-Deschênes in 2021 proposes to age-gate any online platform carrying pornography with the objective of blocking minors from viewing hard-core, often violent, pornography.

The Senate bill overlaps with the Liberal government’s much broader child safety legislation, the Safe Social Media Act. That Bill C-34 empowers a newly set up Digital Safety Commission to age-gate porn on yet-to-be-designated platforms that exceed a viewership or revenue threshold set by cabinet regulation.

In a Substack post, Geist describes the overlap of the two bills as a conflict, opining that S-209 “doubles down on age verification, features inconsistent definitions of pornography, establishes a second penalty regime, and could give the future Digital Safety Commission the power to seek website-blocking orders.”

It’s accurate to say that the S-209 pornography bill raises the legal consequences for pornographers from the threshold set for general child protection purposes in C-34: S-209 features bigger fines, summary convictions for non-compliant pornographers, and website blocking as a last resort.

On the other hand, S-209’s definition of pornography is more narrow than the Liberals’ C-34: in S-209 explicit images of genitalia are not pornographic unless they are intended to cause sexual excitement, seeking to avoid concerns about artistic censorship.

The policy issue that will attract public attention, both for S-209 and C-34, is the age gating requirement. Geist noted in another post that the British government commissioned its regulator Ofcom to surveil the age gating options in advance of its social media ban for minors, due for implementation in the Spring of 2027. Ofcom’s report suggests that it will be necessary for most children and some adults to upload photo ID to third party age verification services.

Both C-34 and S-209 passed second reading in the House of Commons and are destined for study and amendments in Parliamentary committees. It appears however they are going to two different committees: S-209 to Human Resources (HUMA) and C-34 to Heritage (CHPC), which seems cumbersome.

Miville-Deschênes said she was pleasantly surprised by the Liberal government’s change of heart on her bill.

However the government’s true intentions remain cryptic. It’s possible the PMO only prefers not to be caught on the wrong side of public opinion on anything including the words “child” and “pornography.”

Despite the support of the two major Opposition parties, S-209 passed second reading “on division” without a roll call vote of MPs. That suggests there are dissenters. Several Liberal backbenchers spoke in favour and none against. But no cabinet minister took the floor. The Parliamentary Secretary to AI Minister, MP Taleeb Noormohamed, spoke of the good intentions of S-209’s “objectives” but clearly preferred the government’s own bills, C-34 (Safe Social Media Act) and C-36 (Privacy and Data Protection Act). In moving adoption, Liberal backbencher Villeneuve diplomatically described S-209 and C-34 as “closely aligned” and “complementary.”

The tea leaves might be saying that the Liberal plan is to reconcile key differences between S-209 and their own bills: for example the definition of pornography, broader coverage of platforms carrying pornography, or the higher standard for age-gating technology in S-209.

The Liberals might then push C-34 and C-36 ahead of S-209 and let the Senate bill wither in committee.

***

Here’s another MediaPolicy told-you-so: Québec’s Bill 109 is going to create trouble for the federal Liberals.

The provincial legislation passed last December by the now vanquished CAQ government purports to take cultural action in the same legislative space as the federal Online Streaming Act C-11 by setting a library quota for French language shows and songs on streaming platforms like Netflix and Spotify.

The newly sworn provincial cabinet of Parti Québécois Premier Paul St.Pierre-Plamondon is dropping the softer CAQ messaging of working harmoniously with US platforms and adopting a far more muscular tone on cultural policy.

According to the National Post, the Premier intends a 30% content quota for French language media. That figure happens to be the benchmark for the European Union’s framework law that mirrors Québec’s Bill 109 and Canada’s C-11.

The Premier also chose some strident vocabulary in asserting that Ottawa has failed to act decisively on the discoverability of Canadian or French language content. Without endorsing the Premier’s sentiment, that is not an unreasonable claim based on the CRTC’s slow-drip on implementing C-11.

Both the federal C-11 and provincial bill 109 were on the US Trade Representative’’s hit list during the abortive trade talks that broke off in August.

Although the Québec bill is of doubtful constitutional legality ——because it occupies the same legislative space as the federal power over broadcasting policy — the USTR will not care. We should expect to hear more if and when trade talks resume.

***

October was a bad month for Canadian media commentary.

The Hub’s magical Full Press podcast was cancelled after host Harrison Lowman left for a new post as Managing Editor and Host at Canadaland. You can still follow his panelists Peter Menzies and Tara Henley on their Substacks.

Let the “when-will-they-get-back-together” nostalgia begin.

Over the mountains, Vancouver’s Hugh Stephens is pausing his copyright blog . He is taking on a part-time position with the tariff-setting Copyright Board of Canada. That’s one less expert commentary on Canadian copyright and IP issues and, alas, one less voice speaking out against the noxious practice of passing off content theft as fair dealing.

***

If you would like regular notifications of future posts from MediaPolicy.ca you can follow this site by signing up under the Follow button in the bottom right corner of the home page;

or sign up for a free subscription to MediaPolicy.ca on Substack;

or follow
@howardalaw on X or Howard Law on LinkedIn.

I can be reached by e-mail at howard.law@bell.net.

This post is copyrighted by Howard Law, all rights reserved. 2026.


Catching up on MediaPolicy – Trust cascading Canadian journalism – Paramount wins the anti-trust battle – California signs off on news subsidies

October 4, 2026

Millions of students use AI to cheat on their assignments, or so we’ve heard.

So it is no surprise that someone claiming to be a independent journalist would use AI to deceive reputable news agencies.

“Daniel Robson,” now exposed as an alias, succeeded in publishing articles in a string of Canadian news and opinion outlets including The Ottawa Citizen, The Hub, Policy Options, the Montreal Gazette, Open Canada and the Western Standard while faking his identity with an AI photo illustration. He also used an AI large language model to write articles and his e-mail correspondence with editors.

Some of the editors had telephone calls with a human voice calling himself Daniel Robson.

But as the editor of Policy Options Les Perreaux confirmed after discovering the deception :

In reviewing our correspondence and the six other submissions the writer sent us which we did not publish, we have identified signs of AI assistance throughout. Image-analysis tools raised questions about the veracity of the photograph he supplied to us. Last October, he also declined an honorarium we occasionally offer to journalists who write for us – an unusual step for an emerging independent journalist.  

We should have undertaken more verification before publication. I relied too heavily on the fact that work under Daniel Robson’s name had already appeared in other Canadian publications – a form of trust cascade in which publication itself becomes a credential.

The Globe & Mail, which noted it did not accept stories pitched by Robson, has a comprehensive news story here.

A more salacious story appears in the English-language Türkiye Today which alerted the duped Canadian news outlets. The gist of the story is that the mysterious Robson might be a Moroccan intelligence agent engaged in foreign interference with Canadian news outlets.

None of the Canadian news outlets are accusing the writer of civil or criminal fraud.

What struck me about the reporting on “Robson” was what I would call missing the forest for the trees.

This kind of deception —-including the most serious allegation of state-sponsored planting of stories—-is as old as analog. Large language model AI tools make it easier. Burned once by a “trust cascade” of successful publication elsewhere, newsroom editors will wise up. It’s a warning shot. We forgot that AI can do more than create deep fake videos for Russian bot farms to post on Facebook.

What should really concern us is a failure of our human imagination. A lesson is to be learned from the recent website hacking by autonomous AI agents that escaped their sandboxes at OpenAI and other companies.

In the context of journalism, contemplate a rogue “frontier model” AI agent, or an army of state sponsored AI agents, tirelessly probing with sophisticated array of audio, video, text and photo tools until it can pull off an undetected Robson-at-scale penetration of publishing software at multiple news outlets.

***

Prime Minister Mark Carney recently told the New York Times that one of the good things about building stronger Canadian ties with the European Union was that “the Europeans aren’t going to tell us what we have to put on our landing pages of Netflix or Spotify or whatever, and that stuff matters.”

That called for a MediaPolicy drill down on how the Europeans regulate Netflix and the Californian streamers. You can read about it in my post in Cartt.ca.

Also, I recently teamed up with Stephen Stohn to write in the Toronto Star about the importance of Carney standing up for the Online Streaming Act.

***

This week a US federal judge charged with hearing the anti-trust lawsuit brought by California’s Attorney-General and ten other states against the Paramount-Warner Brothers merger signed off on their out-of-court settlement.

The consensus opinion of the deal is that Paramount, owned by David Ellison and debt-financed by his friend-of-Trump father Larry, was the hands down winner.

You can read the bullet-point analysis in Axios. Deeper pieces are available from the New York Times or The Hollywood Reporter.

The settlement features only “behavioural remedies.” That means promises of post-merger good behaviour but no asset divestitures.

For example, the deal blesses Ellison’s ownership of competing cable news networks CBS and CNN on the condition that Ellison convene an editorial board to protect newsroom autonomy.

The outcome was a bit of a surprise.

California’s AG Rob Bonta held high value cards in this poker game. In court he could persuasively tell a judge that the merged studios would unfairly dominate competition between Hollywood studios, supported by major portfolios in cable television, news, and streaming video. He could win.

Bonta also figured to use Ellison’s financing against him in any settlement talks.

Not only is a big piece of the merger debt held against Ellison pater‘s personal fortune, the Ellisons were on the hook for $7 million daily payouts to Warner shareholders, beginning on October 1st, for any delay in getting court approval for the merger. The trial wasn’t even set to kick off until March 2027. That would be at least a $1.7 billion pill for Ellison to swallow.

But Ellison matched Bonta’s chips, smiled, and raised him. He made a bare knuckled threat to move Paramount studios and a successfully merged Warner Brothers out of California to another state. Bonta described this as “blackmail” and initially dug in.

Blackmail or no, Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass begged for settlement. The big Hollywood unions split: IATSE and the Directors Guild for settlement, the Writers and Screen Actors Guilds opposed. The heir apparent to Gavin Newsom in the governor’s mansion, Xavier Becerra, was said to have been swayed by Ellison’s threat.

What tipped the balance was that Californian Democrats blinked. Perhaps eyeing the Democratic Presidential nomination for 2028, Newsom brokered the deal between Ellison and the states.

The deal does not oblige Ellison to keep Paramount Warner in California.

The whole episode was high drama and, for Canadians, reminds one of the Rogers-Shaw merger where the CRTC was sympathetic to Rogers’ pro-merger argument that shifted the focus away from market power wielded against rivals Bell and Telus and towards the creation of a stronger Canadian player fit to take on the media colossi of Netflix, Disney and YouTube. This was the same argument made by the Trump Department of Justice in supporting the Ellisons’ merger.

On a final note: US media is not saying anything about AG Bonta submitting to Governor Newsom. I’m no expert in Californian state law but it appears that the state’s Attorney General does not enjoy the same degree of autonomy from the Governor as we might expect in Canada.

***

As MediaPolicy noted three weeks ago, Californian Democrats pushed a news journalism state subsidy for local news through the state legislature.

Governor Newsom waited until the September 30th deadline and signed off on the bill despite some reservations.

In-state publishers and broadcasters with at least 33% of coverage of Californian current affairs are eligible.

The Californian Community News Act tracks Canada’s federal labour tax credit for hiring and retaining journalists although slightly skewed in favour of smaller news outlets. The Californian dollar amounts are comparable to the Canadian program: $20,000 (USD) per head for the first five journalists and $15,000 thereafter.

California’s projected budget allocation is $40M USD ($57M CDN), covering an estimated 2,600 journalists employed at 600 local news outlets. That is less than Canada’s $75M CDN program for news publishers, covering 3,900 journalists.

In the Californian bill, any new hires that grow the size of the newsroom are supported at $35,000 per salary, a feature rewarding newsroom expansion that Canada’s federal program does not include.

***

If you would like regular notifications of future posts from MediaPolicy.ca you can follow this site by signing up under the Follow button in the bottom right corner of the home page; 

or sign up for a free subscription to MediaPolicy.ca on Substack;

or follow 
@howardalaw on X or Howard Law on LinkedIn.

I can be reached by e-mail at howard.law@bell.net.

This post is copyrighted by Howard Law, all rights reserved. 2026.

Mark Carney, Canada’s cultural export

September 24, 2026

In this historical moment, Prime Minister Mark Carney has become our greatest cultural export. He is considered in his pronouncements, good natured and unflappable. He is the global anti-Trump.

Occasionally, the imperious CEO gets loose. In a rare appearance in the House of Commons for Question Period, Carney was obliged to grind out the parry and return of Opposition barbs.

Having gamely returned service to Pierre Poilievre’s first serves on issues of affordability, Carney swivelled to meet the incoming from Bloc Québécois Leader Yves-François Blanchet on the PM’s repeal of the Digital Services Tax and Netflix cash contributions to Canadian media funds.

“Mr. Speaker,” said Blanchet, “the Prime Minister personally cancelled contributions of any kind by tech giants to the economy or the arts in Quebec and Canada, including through taxes or content creation, simply to appease the American President. The effort fell flat. Although I remain unconvinced, the Prime Minister claims to have walked away from the negotiation table for language and culture-related reasons. Since the effort failed, should the Prime Minister consider reinstating the digital services tax and allowing cultural contributions by the web giants?“

After a reply offered in banal Parliamentary vocabulary, the Prime Minister steadied for Blanchet’s follow up volley.

Blanchet suggested that Carney’s strategy to build closer ties to the European Union meant that Canadian alignment with the EU’s bolder approach to digital taxes and streamer contributions would make sense after breaking off trade talks.

The Prime Minister stood up and delivered a curt, “No, Mr. Speaker.” And sat down. Pointe finale.

Now it helps to watch this on video so you can appreciate the dismissive tone and body language. The clip also captures the bemusement rippling through the Bloc MPs seated behind Blanchet.

As the Prime Minister probably appreciated afterwards, that kind of answer won’t cut it in Québec, a province that loves legislation regulating streamers so much it has two.

***

With the House of Commons sitting again, Parliamentary committees picked up from where they left off in the spring.

In the modern age of an all powerful Prime Minister’s Office, these independent committees frequently resemble teenager house parties when the parents go out of town. Don’t destroy the place and you can do much pretty much anything you want.

The Finance committee is chaired by Karina Gould, the Toronto–area MP and former cabinet minister who made an impressive run for the Liberal leadership in 2025. This week Gould delivered the Liberal committee majority’s report on public submissions for the upcoming 2026 budget.

It’s not all that newsworthy when the Finance Committee reports on its “pre-budget” consultation. Its MPs make loads of budget recommendations in policy areas already covered by fellow MPs sitting on other Parliamentary committees like Canadian Heritage. And in a Budget that remains in the tight fisted grip of the Finance Minister and the PM, the Finance MPs’ recommendations are far from being a first draft of the final Budget.

On culture, the Finance MPs made eleven recommendations.

Some are guaranteed never to see the light of day.

A recommendation that Internet Service Providers (i.e. Bell, Rogers, Québecor) begin paying the same five per cent culture levy that their cable divisions pay is a non-starter.

Recall how in June 2017 Prime Minister Justin Trudeau humiliated Canadian Heritage committee chair and fellow Liberal MP Hedy Fry by holding a pre-emptive news conference to dismiss out of hand her committee’s recommendation favouring an ISP tax.

Other recommendations may be under more serious consideration by the PMO. For example, this omnibus recommendation on public spending on news journalism captures several of them:

Support the sustainability and growth of newsroom jobs by maintaining the Canadian Journalism Labour Tax Credit at the current 35% rate and expanding eligibility criteria to include owner-operators, employees in broadcasting, and partners in news businesses. Budget 2026 should also direct at least 25% of federal advertising spending toward private-sector Canadian news outlets, address disparities in tax treatment for advertising, and extend the Local Journalism Initiative indefinitely to support the creation of original civic journalism in underserved communities. 

The other recommendation that caught my eye was the strengthening of the intellectual property rights of news organizations in response to the ingestion of their content by AI large language models such as ChatGPT, Gemini, and Claude:

The committee further recommends that the Government of Canada protect Canadian news publishers’ intellectual property in the context of artificial intelligence by requiring government AI suppliers to commit to the principles of transparency, consent, and attribution when using copyright-protected content, requesting that the Competition Bureau examine competition issues in search and AI markets, including crawler practices.

And here is a companion recommendation that applies to any kind of Canadian media:

Ensure that artificial intelligence (AI) developers obtain permission and provide compensation for the use of copyright-protected works in training data, reject any new or expanded copyright exceptions for text and data mining, and require transparent disclosure and record-keeping of training sources to support a functioning licensing market.

There are many public policy issues packed into those two paragraphs.

But to news publishers, the issue is simple. They want to be compensated (or even asked permission) by the AI giants for ingesting their content, first for the “training data” that birthed the LLMs’ vocabulary and gave them the context to understand news content, and also for the “output” summaries that LLMs provide to inquisitive users like you and me.

The news publishers’ claim is that AI ingestion is not only without permission and compensation, it’s grabbing intellectual property that news publishers might use to make their own LLMs in open-sourced applications. As well, the LLMs are using ingested news content to create de facto news outlets that directly compete with the news publishers.

Faced with litigation from news publishers, the AI global giants have signed off some pick-and-choose deals with top news outlets.

It’s reminiscent of what happened ten years ago in news hyperlinking by Google and Facebook, ultimately leading to the Online News Act C-18. The web giants made a few deals on the cheap with big news organizations and stonewalled the smaller news publishers.

To those unlucky news outlets, the web giants offered instead free distribution of their hyperlinks in order to draw traffic to their websites. Even if that quid pro quo was ever adequately remunerative to publishers big and small for hyperlinks, it’s not on offer from AI companies for ingestion, including again Google and Meta.

That’s because the notion of an exchange value of “content for traffic” doesn’t apply to AI ingestion of news content that is killing traffic referrals from web platforms to news outlets, as the graph below indicates.

So what next?

There is already litigation over ingestion that will end up in the US Supreme Court and maybe our’s too. The Trump administration has lined up in support the ingesters. The Carney government is sitting on the fence.

His MPs on the Finance committee are recommending he get off of it.

***

If you would like regular notifications of future posts from MediaPolicy.ca you can follow this site by signing up under the Follow button in the bottom right corner of the home page; 

or sign up for a free subscription to MediaPolicy.ca on Substack.

This post is copyrighted by Howard Law, all rights reserved. 2026.

Catching up on MediaPolicy – Support for the Online Streaming Act is up – the story of Global News – California waits for Governor to sign a QCJO bill

September 12, 2026

A new Nanos poll commissioned by Bloomberg News finds increased support for public policy requiring US streamers to contribute financially to Canadian content. 

Support rose from 67% to 73% since Nanos last tested the waters four years ago while the Online Streaming Act was being debated in Parliament. 

Detailed results from the new poll have not been released other than Bloomberg reporting them in a news story. Assuming it’s the same question as the May 2022 poll, respondents were asked whether they believe US streamers should contribute financially to the creation of Canadian content “in the same way” as Canadian broadcasters. 

As an indicator of the intensity of that support in 2022, the 67% yes vote was divided between “support” (39%) and “somewhat support” (28%). Eleven per cent were unsure. Until we get a peek at the full Nanos report, it’s unknown how much those numbers have changed. (Update 14/8/26: the full report shows increased intensity of “support” (48%) and “somewhat support” (25%). The “unsures” are down to 9%).

In any event the new 73% number is a jab in the ribs to Prime Minister Mark Carney who allowed US trade pressure to push him in the opposite direction. In June the Prime Minister overturned the CRTC’s order that the streamers contribute 6.5% of revenues in cash to media financing funds and another 8.5% to their own investments in Canadian shows. Domestic broadcasters contribute a total of 25% of revenues to Canadian content. 

The Carney government is now deliberating its guidance to the CRTC on a new framework for streamer contributions. Even prior to Carney’s intervention, the text of the Online Streaming Act and the CRTC’s implementation of it expected less of foreign streamers than Canadian broadcasters. 

At the time of their intervention, Carney and cultural and identity minister Marc Miller claimed that overruling the CRTC wasn’t a response to US trade pressure but rather their sensitivity to subscription pricing. 

On that note, the Hollywood Reporter has published a sassy story about escalating streaming subscription prices in the US where streamers have been steadily raising prices well above the rate of inflation. The content-lean Apple TV has tripled its price since launch in 2019. Netflix Premium is up 125% since 2013 (while inflation was 38% over that period of time).

***

For those that still admit to having ever met Justin Trudeau (I did, he’s tall!), you’ll be interested to know that the drama teacher has become a drama producer.

No wisecracking, ‘kay? The former PM is going into the independent movie making business with his old sidekick and chief of staff, Katie Telford. Nom de guerre of the new enterprise is Hope and Hard Work.

I will let his press release do the explaining.

***

Steve Faguy has written a well informed and balanced account of the gradual demise, possibly fatal, of Corus Entertainment and its Global News television subsidiary.

He sizes up the various culprits: the Shaw family’s restructuring of its various business divisions and debt loads, the CRTC’s astonishing lethargy, the federal government’s inaction, and Rogers’ cutthroat raid on Corus’ profitable US programming. Like the collective assassins of Julius Caesar, it’s hard to pin the crime on one suspect alone.

Now a penny stock loaded with debt, here’s hoping that Global can survive.

One point Faguy doesn’t make, and it could make all of the difference to Global’s survival, is that the federal government’s Online News Act injects $3.9M annually into the television network. If culture and identity minister Marc Miller follows through with his promise to extend “QCJO” journalist labour tax credits to broadcasters, that’s roughly another $8M.  

In 2025, Global spent $119M on television news programming. According to Unifor, Global has laid off 173 union members since early 2024.

If the QCJO money materializes, it should be announced in the Fall budget.

***

It’s intriguing to follow Californian media policy from afar.

As the home turf of Big Tech and Hollywood, you might expect corporate interests to dictate public policy.

Not necessarily.

When five Democratic federal congress representatives from California joined House Republicans in condemning Canada’s Online Streaming Act, the remaining 47 congress representatives did not. Neither did the state’s two Senators.

At the state level, the legislature is Democrat-controlled from top to bottom and elected officials insist on lobbing hot potatoes in the lap of Governor Gavin Newsom. 

Over the course of twenty-four months culminating this August, Newsom endorsed, gutted and then revived the state Assembly’s modest Californian knock-off of Canada’s Online News Act, based on matching $20 million contributions from Google and the state.

Now the legislature has overwhelmingly passed AB2222, the Community News Act. The Canadian policy analogy would be the federal labour tax credit on journalist salaries. Newsom has until the end of the month to sign it, or it dies.

The Community News Act tracks our QCJO labour tax credit for hiring and retaining journalists. The dollar amounts are comparable: $20,000 (USD) per head for the first five journalists and $15,000 thereafter. Any new hires that grow the size of the newsroom are supported at $35,000 per salary.

***

If you would like regular notifications of future posts from MediaPolicy.ca you can follow this site by signing up under the Follow button in the bottom right corner of the home page; 

or sign up for a free subscription to MediaPolicy.ca on Substack;

or follow 
@howardalaw on X or Howard Law on LinkedIn.

COMMENTS ARE WELCOME. But be advised they are public once I hit the “approve” button, so mark them private if you don’t want them approved. 

I can be reached by e-mail at howard.law@bell.net.

This post is copyrighted by Howard Law, all rights reserved. 2026.

The Trump carpetbaggers pillaging Canada

Satiric AI illustration based on Thomas Nast’s Harpers Weekly illustration, 1872

September 2, 2026

The epithet “Carpetbaggers” has an evocative history in the United States. 

It was how post-Civil War white southerners described opportunistic northern merchants who descended upon the war-devastated former slave states.

The same vitriolic insult was conferred upon the corps of northern abolitionists and office-seekers who arrived to mobilize the Black vote for newly created state legislatures, the entire chapter in American history known since as the Reconstruction era.

After Reconstruction ended in the 1876 sell-out of Black civil rights and the wage re-enslavement of African Americans, the term Carpetbaggers became more generic. Wikipedia describes it as “denot[ing] people who move into a new area for purely economic or political reasons despite having no ties to that place.”

Lately the California-headquartered streamers operating in Canada have earned the Carpetbagger sobriquet. 

The streamers don’t own our broadcasting market, not yet. Canadian owned television and radio broadcasting is slowly diminishing but it remains significant. Our cable and satellite-borne audio visual signals reach 9 million out of 15 million Canadian households.

But Netflix reportedly reaches about 9.8 million Canadian subscribers. With the grey market in password sharing, that is probably well over 10 million households. The other US streamers Amazon Prime (7.5m), Disney (6m) and Paramount (5.3m) are all ahead of the HBO-boosted Bell Crave (5m). According to the CRTC, three out of four Canadians reported subscribing to an audio-visual streaming service, compared to a little over half of Canadian households (58%) subscribing to a traditional television service.

That dominant American share of our streaming market means that Canadian subscriber dollars, advertising revenues, and reinvestment capacity generated by Canadian profits all flow south. 

As a caveat to that generalization, there is a debate (impoverished by the lack of data) over how much money Netflix and the streamers voluntarily invest in English language Canadian content as equity partners. Canadians are also familiar with the occasional appearance of Canadian themed Netflix originals such as the upcoming Below or Amazon’s The Sticky. 

But the yawning gap between how much Canadian broadcasters are required by the CRTC to invest in Canadian content —-30% of their revenue—- and the goose egg obligations for streamers can only be described as Carpetbagging. 

The federal government has taken a couple of stabs at remedying that extraction of value. 

One attempt was the ill-fated $1 billion per year Digital Services Tax on the streamers (but also other digital businesses like Uber). 

When this kind of tax was developed a decade ago in Europe, it was a counterweight to American Big Tech’s avoidance of local corporate taxes by parking their profits in tax havens. By the time Canada got around to legislating our own DST, the federal Liberals never clarified whether it was plugging the corporate tax hole or simply reshoring a share of the streamers’ revenue extraction from Canada. 

As you know, Prime Minister Carney gave the DST away in June 2025 when President Trump demanded it. I am sure Carney now regrets that as a bad bet on the President’s intentions.

The second attempt to remedy the California streamers’ value extraction was the Online Streaming Act. 

You know the story here. The latest chapter is that in 2024 the CRTC imposed a five per cent cash levy on the US streamers, the same that Canadian cable companies pay. Those levies feed the Canada Media Fund and a number of similar production funds that finance Canadian content shows. Those shows are made by independent Canadian producers who license them back to Canadian broadcasters and (once the three-year old Online Streaming Act is actually applied) to US streamers. The key point is that the shows are licensed at a lower price because of the media fund money that gets invested up front.

Not good enough for the Carpetbaggers. Even after Mark Carney overruled the CRTC and rid them of the levies, they weren’t satisfied. That was confirmed when the streamers were able to get the White House to push for the evisceration of another Online Streaming Act tool, the surfacing of Canadian content on US streaming platforms, on the very last day of trade talks. 

The reason that the streamers deserve the unsavoury Carpetbagger label is because they have worked so hard to earn it. 

Before Donald Trump began his second term in 2025, a more compliant Netflix told the CRTC they could live with a two per cent cash levy (provided none of it went to news). Canadian cable companies pay double that, at 4 per cent.

Ah, but that was then and this is now. At the moment, the Netflix position in Canada is no regulation, no obligations. Full value extraction from Canadian subscribers and advertisers.

And to make this happen, the streamers have been able to insinuate their influence into the ground zero of trade talks.

Writing about this back in 2024 in Cartt.ca, I noted the Netflix “strategy appears to be oppose, appeal, and get the attention of the next U.S. president, U.S. Congress and U.S. trade representative.” 

And here we are. 

***

One of the trade files that went quiet for the last few months was Donald Trump’s threats beginning in 2025 to put a tariff on US movies shot in Canada, destined for the American, Canadian and global markets.

That’s not what the streamers and big studios wanted from him. They like shooting some of their shows abroad in the UK, Canada, and Europe, all of which have world-class production clusters and a Rolidex of trusted production partners. The analogy of the integrated US-Canada automotive market applies here.

The industry backdrop to this is that, post-pandemic, Los Angeles has endured a substantial drop off in its market share of American film and TV production, losing work to other US states and other countries. The end of the “streaming wars” and its profligate spending is also a factor. Some states, like California, have aggressively stepped into the subsidy space in order to reclaim work. But US Congress has not.

It looks like months of federal lobbying has paid off for the streamers because this week President Trump came out in favour of a federal film production tax credit. While California and other US states have increased their own subsidies, the US does not have a federal counterpart. In Canada, we combine federal and provincial production subsidies made available to both Canadian and foreign studios making shows here.

Canada has been smart about building a world class audio-visual production industry. It is in fact our domestic industry’s financial ballast.

To the extent that a US federal subsidy succeeds in American studios reshoring production, that will impact us. 

***

MediaPolicy has been following the big Meta settlement with 48 US states (Florida is not settling) on the product liability lawsuit against Instagram and Facebook. 

There is a good post-game analysis in the New York Times.

Meta’s lawyer is C.J. Mahoney. He was the US Deputy Trade Representative during the 2018 CUSMA talks (isn’t that an interesting connection between Big Tech and the Trump White House!).

The Times story reports that Mahoney stick handled his client’s settlement with the states after individual plaintiffs won the precedent setting jury trials in California and New Mexico resulting in hundreds of millions of dollars of damages awarded against Meta.

Those trials and related litigation proved that Meta can not successfully hide behind the “free speech” shield in the famous section 230 of the Clinton-era Communications Decency Act.

From there, it was all downhill sledding for the state Attorneys General.  

And importantly for Canada, despite binding ourselves to Big Tech’s section 230 defence in the 2018 CUSMA digital chapter (clause 19.17.2), the reversal of Meta’s fortunes means that the federal Safe Social Media Act Bill C-34 is in principle not a violation of that agreement, vindicated by rulings in the American courts. 

Another backbone moment in this story was demonstrated by the state Attorneys General who rebuffed Mahoney’s offer to settle for damages only. They held out for the product safety changes to protect children logging on to Facebook and Instagram. Credit the parent groups and children’s advocates who fought for that and made the states accountable to them.

According to the Times, the settlement’s die was cast before last month’s big trial even began but it took some time to line up agreement from the various states. The key was coming up with a fair allocation of the $18B USD in damages that will go to children’s mental health programs. 

In the end, all 49 states fell into line except Texas (which settled separately shortly afterwards) and Florida. 

The Florida suit will proceed as will many others, but one would expect that judges will engage in some extraordinary arm twisting in chambers with the plaintiffs’ lawyers to get them to fall in line with the Big Settlement.  

Two remaining Big Questions are whether the Meta settlement gets adopted by competitors YouTube, TikTok and Snap and whether the safety upgrades helps Congress get to a deal on federal legislation.

***

Oops.

In my last post I wrote that “a leaked page grab from an internal Canadian Heritage document suggests that the $600 million will cover the $134 million in foregone streamer payments to Canadian audiovisual media funds for broadcast news and Canadian content.”

I made a mistaken assumption about the document’s authorship based on Globe & Mail journalist Barry Hertz’s tweet about the allocation numbers and Heritage Canada failing to confirm or deny to me when I asked if it was a Heritage document.

I have now discovered that the document in question is in fact an industry stakeholder’s summary of what the stakeholder was told verbally by a Heritage Canada source. The stakeholder contacted me this morning to clarify. 

Hertz’s tweet indicates that according to Heritage the numbers cited in the stakeholder document were “not final.” I will leave it there.

***

If you would like regular notifications of future posts from MediaPolicy.ca you can follow this site by signing up under the Follow button in the bottom right corner of the home page; 

or sign up for a free subscription to MediaPolicy.ca on Substack;

or follow 
@howardalaw on X or Howard Law on LinkedIn.

COMMENTS ARE WELCOME. But be advised they are public once I hit the “approve” button, so mark them private if you don’t want them approved. 

I can be reached by e-mail at howard.law@bell.net.

This post is copyrighted by Howard Law, all rights reserved. 2026.

“Knowing those [streamer] players as we do, they were not going to say, ‘Thank you very much. We’re done.’ They were only going to regard that as the appetizer.”

August 29, 2026

The how and why of last Friday’s breakdown in US-Canadian trade talks preoccupied us for most of last week.

The Canadians weighed in on why things went sideways after Trump announced a “deal” several days before the deadline. The Americans spun their narrative in the other direction. Commerce secretary Howard Lutnick’s performance is not to be missed.

It would help to know what was in those negotiating documents that will never become public. Or to start demanding polygraphs that will never be taken.

Without those here is my take, based on what negotiators said and what might have happened.

Carney and Trump talked on the Tuesday night. Clearly they agreed on something. Probably it was some high level numbers on key tariffs. Looking for a public win, Trump couldn’t restrain himself and rushed to announce a deal the next morning. The key thing is that Trump thought he had hooked Carney by giving him enough and that the US would then steamroller the Canadians on the fine print and all of the remaining issues. Saying there was already a deal was part of his strategy.

That is the bargaining dynamic that often occurs when one negotiating party has, or believes it has, the hammer. Trump expected to run the table. If there was any truth to the rumours of the impending demise of the Online News Act, the Canadian team was half expecting the same.

But Trump miscalculated and overreached. On trucks and pickups. On culture. On Canada’s options to make other trade deals without Trump’s permission. This provided an opportunity for Ontario premier Doug Ford to signal Carney that he was about to go offside. Manitoba premier Wab Kinew already was. The Bloc Québécois was making noise about cultural concessions.

When CBC interviewed Trump’s trade envoy Jamieson Greer on Thursday he claimed that the cultural issue embedded in the federal Online Streaming Act —-repeatedly and narrowly confined to “the discoverability of French language content”—- was, shucks, never a big deal for the US. 

“It’s the furthest thing from a red line,” Greer told CBC host Rosemary Barton. “We highlighted [it at the end] yes, but our view is you should let capitalism do its thing and let people pick. We know it’s important to people in Quebec….We would not have let it get in the way of a good deal.” (Roll the video from the nine minute mark).

Slick and slippery, yes. But more likely a sign that Trump thought the Canadians were already hooked and would swallow anything to get a deal across the line.

Greer still found time to have another moan to CBC’s Barton about streamer cash payments to Canadian media funds: “What we don’t like is a situation where Canada forces American tech companies to take their earnings to give a percentage to their competitors.”

Putting aside that mischaracterization of how cash payments to media funds get recycled to all contributors, Carney had already taken them off the table three months ago by overruling the CRTC.

Yet here Greer was still fixated on them, raising them on both Canadian and US television networks, even after the breakdown of talks and in the same breath in which he claimed that “the French language” issue raised by the federal Online Streaming Act and Québec’s counterpart Bill 109 was no big deal.

Canada’s trade envoy Dominic Leblanc responded to Greer’s claims tactically. He publicly thanked the Americans for taking the streamer issue off the table. 

While Leblanc was thanking Greer, the Canadian cultural community was effusively and publicly thanking Carney for fending off the Americans. 

Every iota of that effusiveness was proportional to a residual mistrust that the Online Streaming Act and the Online News Act are off the table for good, or that a Prime Minister who would give away the digital services tax for nothing, humiliate the CRTC by overruling their implementation of cash payments, and for Pete’s sake would even submit to a shameless Trump shakedown on a bridge we paid for, might yet fold again on culture.

Reynolds Mastin of the Canadian producers’ union CMPA, which has emerged as the de facto spokesperson for the English-language cultural community, described the near-death of the Online Streaming Act as “an inflection point” for Canadian culture and trade talks.

Mastin also politely chided the Carney government if it had indeed assumed that its climb down on the streamer payments in June had sated the US streamers’ hunger to get rid of the OSA altogether. “Knowing those players as we do, they were not going to say, ‘Thank you very much. We’re done.’ They were only going to regard that as the appetizer.”

This weekend Mastin’s CMPA and another 40 cultural organizations took the time and expense to express their gratitude to Carney “for standing up for Canada’s cultural sovereignty” in full-page newspaper ads. Newsmedia Canada’s Paul Deegan did much the same on the Online News Act. 

In Québec, the Coalition for the Diversity of Cultural Expression went a step further, calling for Carney to throw it into reverse gear and reinstate the $200 million in audio-visual and audio streamer payments. 

Carney is now in a pickle of his own making. 

The Americans may or may not have let go of the cultural concessions. All it would take to revive them is an American reporter asking Trump the question.

Canadians have increasingly seen cultural issues as a defining issue of our dignity and resistance to Trump humiliation, at high levels of support that were already elevated according to year-old public polling. 

Meanwhile Carney has his $600 million pot of cultural spending that, contrary to MediaPolicy’s initial skepticism, might actually be doing something more than taking the sting out of his climb down on cultural issues. 

A leaked page grab from an internal Canadian Heritage document suggests that the $600 million will cover the $134 million in foregone streamer payments to Canadian audiovisual media funds for broadcast news and Canadian content. But the document also suggests that the remaining “unallocated” $467M is earmarked for “additional audiovisual stabilization funding” and the “audio sector.”

The vagueness of this $467 million commitment may sustain skeptics like myself. But other internal documents from Heritage suggest an earnest and far reaching rethink of how to spend not only the $467M but all of the $850 million in various federal programs for audio visual production on a growth and export strategy for Canadian content.

I’ve buried the lede here. More to come on that. 

***

If you would like regular notifications of future posts from MediaPolicy.ca you can follow this site by signing up under the Follow button in the bottom right corner of the home page; 

or sign up for a free subscription to MediaPolicy.ca on Substack;

or follow 
@howardalaw on X or Howard Law on LinkedIn.

COMMENTS ARE WELCOME. But be advised they are public once I hit the “approve” button, so mark them private if you don’t want them approved. 

I can be reached by e-mail at howard.law@bell.net.

This post is copyrighted by Howard Law, all rights reserved. 2026.