How Carney’s $600M culture budget compares to the CRTC Netflix tax he killed

(AI illustration)

November 9, 2026

How does Prime Minister Carney’s $600 million make-good for Canadian content compare to the money he nixed back in June, the CRTC’s $200 million cash levies on foreign video and audio streamers?

I do love a bar graph (or five). Nevertheless, these snapshots reveal only one side of the elephant (I’ll explain below).

Here is Table 1. It demonstrates the policy problem. As conventional broadcasting has declined since its peak in 2017, so have the CRTC-mandated contributions to Canadian media Funds that supplement private investment and public funding.

The Canada Media Fund finances Canadian dramas, documentaries and children’s programming.

Other TV Production Funds include corporately sponsored (e.g. Bell, Québecor or Rogers) or specialty (e.g. Indigenous and Black Screen Offices) Funds. They play a similar role to the Canada Media Fund.

Local Independent TV News pays the bills for a big portion of newsroom expenditures for Independent local TV stations such as Hamilton’s CHCH-TV and Gatineau’s CHOT-TV. It excludes national networks like CTV, TVA and City-TV but now includes Global News because it’s no longer owned by a cable company.

All Radio and Music Funds include the suite of musician development organizations (e.g. FACTOR, Starmaker and their French language compatriots) as well as the Community Radio Fund of Canada and the Indigenous Music Office.

Many of these Funds receive both support from CRTC levies and government subsidies.

(Notes 1 and 2 below correspond to Table 1).

You see the decline. But of course it’s worse when the funding data is adjusted for inflation, so here’s Table 2 which does that by restating the 2017 funding in 2025 dollars. In this table, the funding decline is more pronounced:

That’s the policy problem. What about the remedy? Table 3 was the ill-fated CRTC solution to the problem by levying an estimated $200M (in 2024 dollars) of annual contributions from Netflix, Spotify and the other streaming services:

On to the next concept. As I said, many of these CRTC-supported Funds have been historically co-financed with direct government contributions. After striking down the CRTC’s Netflix tax, Carney’s $600M make-good pot of federal money can be compared to contributions made by Canadian broadcasters in Table 4. (Notes 3,4,5)

And finally Table 5 illustrates how Carney’s $600M for the 2026/27 budget year compares to federal spending in the previous year:

Here are some notes and caveats:

(1) I sourced this data using my AI Chatbot, Perplexity. I like that product because it shows sources and conflicts in data collection. I would normally drill down into the actual sources to verify, but in this case it would be too time consuming.

There could be all sorts of problems with data or unrevealed assumptions. For example, it’s possible that “one-time” regulatory or government contributions are included in an annual figure. Reader beware.

(2) The “Viewing” data in Table 1 is a proxy for broadcaster and streamer revenue earned from subscriptions and advertising dollars. I am seeking to illustrate the criss-crossing fortunes of traditional television and streaming.

(3) We should be careful about assuming the $600M in government funding will be there again in 2027/28, let alone in five or ten years. My guess is that the government will re-evaluate the whole scheme once the CRTC has implemented Carney’s forthcoming policy direction on how much to demand from broadcasters and streamers in direct investments in Canadian content for their own platforms.

Also, the $600 million includes cultural spending that does not correspond to any CRTC levy, for example Telefilm ($68M) and the Canada History Fund ($5M). Also, the $600M includes $42M to replace CRTC-ordered cable company expenditures on television channels deemed by the Commission to be “services of exceptional importance” such as CPAC, TV5 or APTN.

(4) We should also keep in mind that although the $600M is for budget year 2026/27 it may represent more than just twelve months of funding. It is probably intended to make up for the loss of Netflix Tax contributions in both 2025/26 and 2026/27.

(5) The spectacular increase in funding for the Independent Local TV News Fund should be considered in the context that the number of local stations supported by the Fund has doubled from 17 to 35, owing to the participation of the Global News network of stations.

***

If you would like regular notifications of future posts from MediaPolicy.ca you can follow this site by signing up under the Follow button in the bottom right corner of the home page;

or sign up for a free subscription to MediaPolicy.ca on Substack;

or follow
@howardalaw on X or Howard Law on LinkedIn.

I can be reached by e-mail at howard.law@bell.net.

This post is copyrighted by Howard Law, all rights reserved. 2026.

$600 million to replace Netflix tax announced by Canadian Heritage

November 8, 2026

On a Sunday afternoon, three hours from story deadline, Heritage minister Marc Miller gave news organizations something to publish for the notoriously light Monday edition: the long awaited details of $600 million in additional cultural spending for 2026/27.

The federal money was promised in June as a make-good for Prime Minister Mark Carney’s decision to give Netflix, Spotify and other foreign streamers a break on paying cash levies to Canadian media funds.

Those Canadian media funds feed into existing public and private funding for Canadian news and entertainment programming.

The allocation of the one-time $600 million —three times the $200 million in annual streamer payments cancelled by Carney— may in fact cover more than a full fiscal year of forgiven streamer contributions that were to take effect on September 1, 2025.

The big recipients are:

  • The Canada Media Fund, financing television dramas, documentaries and children’s programming.
  • The Indigenous Screen Office, Black Screen Office, and a variety of corporate-sponsored television funds performing a similar function to the CMF.
  • Local news and community broadcasting funds including the Independent Local News Fund (i.e. not TVA, Rogers or Bell) and the Commercial Radio News Fund.
  • The Community Radio Fund.
  • “Services of exceptional importance such as CPAC, APTN and TV5.”
  • The government’s Canada Music Fund that funnels support for Canadian musicians to various industry-managed Funds, as well as the newly established Indigenous Music Office.

Three other media funds that were not tipped by the CRTC’s June 2024 levy on foreign streamers will also see cash from the government’s $600 million:

More to come.

***

If you would like regular notifications of future posts from MediaPolicy.ca you can follow this site by signing up under the Follow button in the bottom right corner of the home page;

or sign up for a free subscription to MediaPolicy.ca on Substack;

or follow
@howardalaw on X or Howard Law on LinkedIn.

I can be reached by e-mail at howard.law@bell.net.

This post is copyrighted by Howard Law, all rights reserved. 2026.

Budget 2026 strengthens news funding, cuts CBC dollars, and leaves CanCon hanging

(AI illustration)

November 7, 2026

Finance minister François-Philippe Champagne’s Budget 2026 proposes substantial cultural spending including greater support for privately owned news media.

Here is a rundown, beginning with news journalism.

The five-year federal journalist salary subsidy to news organizations introduced in 2020 has been extended yet again, to 2031/32.

The Journalism Labour Tax Credit‘s temporary bump (since 2023) from 25% to 35% of salaries is extended by Budget 2026 for two more years, to the end of calendar year 2028. The 2023 elevation of the cap on subsidized salaries to $85,000 appears to be permanent.

More journalists will qualify. As Culture & Identity minister Marc Miller announced in March, the JLTC is now available to video and audio broadcasters, effectively doubling the number of journalist positions supported by the program to 7,500. Once the 35% falls back to 25% in 2029, the government projects an annual $85M budget line. The current program cost is $75M.

Aside from the JLTC, the Carney government reshuffled the remainder of federal support targeting smaller news outlets.

The $21M annual funding for the Local Journalism Initiative is increased to $33 million for the next four years and then again to $41M in the fifth year in what the budget document describes as “ongoing” funding.

At the moment, LJI money is allocated by an industry committee and supports about 700 reporter positions at 350 news organizations. Having aggressively expanded the number of positions over several years without an increase in funding, the LJI’s salary subsidy currently floats around 40% of journalist pay instead of full salary as originally designed. Private broadcasters are not eligible for the LJI and this did not change in Budget 2026.

More money for local news, yes, but the doubling of funding for the Local Journalism Initiative is effectively offset by the reduction of $13M to the $85M Canadian Periodical Fund for magazines, digital periodicals and community newspapers and a further $14M in 2028/29. (Note: News organizations cannot collect the JLTC subsidy and the Periodical Fund in the same year).

And more reshuffling of funding, the government’s $2M reduction of its $13M annual contribution to the French language TV5, announced in the Main Parliamentary Estimates in February, remains in place.

As for CBC/Radio-Canada, the Liberal government confirmed a two-year renewal of the $150M funding increase that it campaigned on in the 2025 election as the first rung in a laddered increase to bring the public broadcaster’s Parliamentary grant more in line with European benchmarks.

From Liberal Party platform (2025)

But the government did not go further up the ladder and even failed to renew the $42M in CBC funding that the Trudeau administration introduced in 2024 as a response to the broadcaster’s plan to lay off hundreds of employees, a reduction not mentioned in its campaign document. Once Budget 2026 passes, the Parliamentary grant will be approximately $1.53 billion to cover an expanded mandate, especially more local news. That’s a 16% increase in real dollars, post-inflation, since the Trudeau Liberals were elected in 2015.

The CBC employs about a third of Canada’s 11,000 professional journalists and editorial staff.

Meanwhile, federal CanCon funding for entertainment video, music and books remains unclear.

In February, Ottawa announced a $68M cut to its $203M (in 2025/26) annual federal contribution to the Canada Media Fund. The CMF juices private and public investment in Canadian dramas, documentaries and kids’ television programming. It is co-funded with Canadian cable TV companies and it was poised—until the Carney government struck down the CRTC’s ruling last June— to get funding from Netflix and the other Californian streaming services.

It’s almost certain that minister Miller intends to give the CMF a healthy slice of the previously announced $600 million in new funding, a make good for the Prime Minister’s regulatory relief for Netflix et al. Budget 2026 did not provide any itemization of the $600M or a timetable for further announcements.

Canadian books were front of mind in Budget 2026. A national online lending library of Canadian literature is in the works at the cost of about $9 million annually to cover copyright fees for publishers and authors. As for the Canada Book Fund —which supplements Canada Council grants to underwrite Canadian-authored books— the projected $3.4 million cut to its $40M budget appears to have been replaced with a $5M increase to its annual budget.

The $16M cut to the federal government’s $40M contribution to the Canada Music Fund —-supporting Canadian musicians’ production and touring expenses— previously announced in February 2026 was cancelled when Budget 2025 received Royal Assent the following month, extending the $16M in funding for three more years.

Aside from these existing programs, the Finance minister announced an attention-grabbing budget line item: a personal income tax break for an as yet unidentified cohort of Canadian creative artists.

Dubbed the Canada Creative Credit, but perhaps better described as the starving artists’ tax deduction, the program will raise the effective threshold for tax free income combined with the Basic Personal Amount “up to $45,000 of annual qualifying net business income derived from original and creative artistic works.” The tax saving might be as much as $4,000 for each artist. The Finance minister did not offer a price tag for the tax expenditure.

The special tax status for artists is similar to programs in Ireland, France and the province of Québec.

The Liberals did not campaign on this item in 2025 and no public consultation was held so the shape of the program is unclear. Details were promised for the spring of 2027. One thing to watch is whether the program will apply to the growing ranks of YouTubers and online influencers who create original content and what kind of media content is contemplated. Freelance writers and photographers are another potential category of creators. The income tax relief was one of several policy proposals put forward by Richard Stursberg for Canadian book publishing in his recent book Lament for a Literature.

Caveat emptor readers, I expect I have will have some corrections or revisions to this post. The ministry of Finance did not respond by my deadline to a series of requested clarifications.

***

One of the big things left hanging by Budget 2026 is how and when the $600M in promised cultural funding, linked by minister Miller to cancelling streamer levies, will be allocated. Budget 2026 only made reference to a single year of this special funding although Miller has told reporters it is intended to be permanent.

In any event, two weeks ago I listed the top items on the Carney government’s To Do list for media funding. Here’s a reminder:

  • The federal budget clarifies when and how the $600 million in cultural spending is to be allocated.
  • That includes the fate of the apparent spending cuts for the CBC, the Canada Media Fund, the Canada Book Fund, Canada Music Fund, Canadian Periodical Fund, and the French language TV5.
  • The government is then cleared to publish its policy direction to the CRTC on what it wants to see in terms of streamer contributions to Canadian content. The CRTC will have to decide whether to hold another round of lengthy public hearings and written submissions or to cut to the chase and simply rewrite the rulings that the Carney government appears to have vacated.
  • The government will also have the opportunity to publish its revised policy governing the structure and mandate of federal video production tax credits, the Canada Media Fund, Telefilm, and the National Film Board.

***

In late October I told you about Meta’s latest content grab where it claimed the right to ingest the full editorial archive of any news organization using its AI products, even if the content was not posted to Meta platforms.

CEO Mark Zuckerberg has now backed down, at least temporarily, by announcing a “pause” on its unilateral change to terms and conditions for business accounts.

***

If you would like regular notifications of future posts from MediaPolicy.ca you can follow this site by signing up under the Follow button in the bottom right corner of the home page;

or sign up for a free subscription to MediaPolicy.ca on Substack;

or follow
@howardalaw on X or Howard Law on LinkedIn.

I can be reached by e-mail at howard.law@bell.net.

This post is copyrighted by Howard Law, all rights reserved. 2026.

Meta’s next content grab – Interim online child safety codes – AI innovation and Canadian newsrooms

(AI illustration)

October 28, 2026

There are times when you think that Meta’s Mark Zuckerberg has no interest in shedding his cred as Big Tech’s baddest boy.

Last week Brazil’s Workers’ Party government accused Meta of interfering in the Presidential election by pumping the algorithmic tires of his right-wing rival Flávio Bolsanaro while suppressing incumbent Luis Lula da Silva’s social media content.

Zuckerberg denies the allegation.

Unfortunately his reputation precedes him: no one has forgotten Meta’s political interference in the Cambridge Analytica scandal that cost Meta billions in fines. Or Meta’s years of hosting and promoting toxic content on Instagram and Facebook. Or, closer to home for Canadians, the Meta sabotage of the Online News Act with its content ban on mainstream news organizations.

Zuckerberg’s latest caper is an update of its take-it-or-leave-it terms and conditions for Facebook and Insta business accounts, including the accounts of news organizations.

One significant change is Meta explicitly claiming the right to ingest all media content for the purpose of AI training. The word “training” was removed after protests, but it remains implied in the grammar of the new legalese. A bigger change was the widened scope of the content grabbing: not just posted articles but allegedly the entire website associated with the account holder.

News organizations would then have a choice: get off of Facebook and Instagram or surrender all of your online content, including the archive.

A caveat is that Meta has made a non-binding promise in a press release to respect crawler-blocking robot.txt instructions used by website-hosts to block scraping. But technically that scraping block can be evaded by crawlers and Zuckerberg’s promise is not part of the revised terms and conditions, probably because it would neutralize the content grab that Meta is reaching for.

It’s a global play by Meta and the hornet’s nest has been well poked. As the November 20th deadline for the escalated crawling approaches, news organizations have a decision to make.

A National Post opinion editorial co-written by News Media Canada’s Paul Deegan confirms most Canadian online news outlets are affected. But of course mainstream outlets are already blocked from posting news content on their own accounts, so their account pages look like this:

***

In MediaPolicy’s recent comment on the Safe Social Media Act C-34, we mooted the wisdom of front-loading more of the expected child safety features in the legislation instead of delegating the task to a digital regulator that will take months to set up, more months to consider safety codes that social media companies will likely under-design anyway, and yet more months for the regulator to review and impose stronger measures.

And in the meantime the bill requires a temporary ban on children’s accounts that a majority of kids will evade anyway.

In a Substack column, Andrew MacDougall expressed a public policy impatience that would probably resonate with most parents:

A different debate would be had if the government were to come out and specify some product design features they don’t want to see in children’s social media accounts. After all, most of the harms follow on from the product design features of social media platforms. The reason kids have been shown self-harm content is because kids express an interest in that content and the algorithm then serves them more. The reason some kids obsess over their social media output is because the platforms have social validators in the form of like and share counts.

But what if we binned off those product design features? What if the government told the platforms removing those features was a precondition for being considered safe? You can’t sell a car without seatbelts or a drug that doesn’t pass trials, so why can you flog a platform without comparable safety features?

Put differently, would we need suggested daily time limits if the social media platforms didn’t have product design features like infinite scroll, auto-play for videos, or algorithmic recommendation systems? What if they gave us something closer to OG social media, when all we had was a reverse chronological feed of content from the people we chose to connect to? Would that be safer? It would certainly be more boring and less lucrative for the platforms.

In other words, why not write some tough standards for social media companies right into the bill?

Any overreach could be cropped back later and, as incentive for social media platforms to make their first pitch their best, an interim safety code might be preferable to an interim ban on children’s accounts.

***

When I last wrote about AI in newsrooms I meandered through some potential innovations in audience tools and platform monetization we might see in the near future, assuming rogue AI agents haven’t scorched the Earth by then.

At the UK’s Daily Telegraph, the new German owners Axel Springer have pulled back the curtain on big changes including newsroom layoffs, improved efficiency something-something, and —of greater interest— the “reinvention of the reader experience” by relying on technology, data and AI.

There wasn’t much more detail provided by Telegraph management than a directional statement. There was a cryptic reference to focussing on new revenue streams including “video, audio, puzzles, events, B2B, licensing, commerce and new products.”

If that statement is intended to convey an AI-based plan to reconstitute “the bundle” of news and non-news content at which newspapers excelled prior to the content-fragmentation of the Internet, the fate of the The Telegraph will be something to keep tabs on.

As I mentioned in my previous column, Canada’s own Village Media is setting an example in developing its own AI interface to connect readers to community resources.

This raises the question of whether AI can be more than just a threat to wipe out news organizations with Chatbots and more than just a tempting short-cut for newsrooms and journalists.

The larger news outlets have the capital and human resources to succeed at this. Just to take another example, the Wall Street Journal used an AI tool to ingest 25 million TikTok videos and 500,000 podcasts to analyze news content reaching voters in the US mid-terms.

You could see the Globe and Mail or La Presse imitating or even escalating this kind of innovation. Historically they have been the apex innovators in Canadian news media, along with Village Media. But what about the metropolitan or local news outlets who hardly have the time, money or expertise to get on the AI innovation train? It’s hard to sprint in the middle of a marathon.

To segue from this point, I recently reviewed the federal Heritage Department’s report on the consultation it did with Canadian publishers on the administration of the Canadian Periodical Fund and the Local Journalism Initiative, two programs that support local news with newsroom subsidies.

What I discovered in its 28 pages was the industry participants’ unfortunate preoccupation with reapportioning subsidies from large and group publishers to the benefit of small and independent outlets.

What was missing was a preoccupation with innovation, although it did not go completely unmentioned.

The lack of enthusiasm was perhaps not surprising given that Heritage did not renew its short lived Business Innovation Fund in 2024 because —I was informed by an industry source — of undersubscription. In the new report, the idea of an AI Skills and Experimentation Fund was raised by magazine publishers, not news outlets.

As AI rolls over the news media industry, it really looks like Heritage should be considering how to play matchmaker between local news organizations and AI tools and products.

***

If you would like regular notifications of future posts from MediaPolicy.ca you can follow this site by signing up under the Follow button in the bottom right corner of the home page;

or sign up for a free subscription to MediaPolicy.ca on Substack;

or follow
@howardalaw on X or Howard Law on LinkedIn.

I can be reached by e-mail at howard.law@bell.net.

This post is copyrighted by Howard Law, all rights reserved. 2026.

Catching up on MediaPolicy – Trust cascading Canadian journalism – Paramount wins the anti-trust battle – California signs off on news subsidies

October 4, 2026

Millions of students use AI to cheat on their assignments, or so we’ve heard.

So it is no surprise that someone claiming to be a independent journalist would use AI to deceive reputable news agencies.

“Daniel Robson,” now exposed as an alias, succeeded in publishing articles in a string of Canadian news and opinion outlets including The Ottawa Citizen, The Hub, Policy Options, the Montreal Gazette, Open Canada and the Western Standard while faking his identity with an AI photo illustration. He also used an AI large language model to write articles and his e-mail correspondence with editors.

Some of the editors had telephone calls with a human voice calling himself Daniel Robson.

But as the editor of Policy Options Les Perreaux confirmed after discovering the deception :

In reviewing our correspondence and the six other submissions the writer sent us which we did not publish, we have identified signs of AI assistance throughout. Image-analysis tools raised questions about the veracity of the photograph he supplied to us. Last October, he also declined an honorarium we occasionally offer to journalists who write for us – an unusual step for an emerging independent journalist.  

We should have undertaken more verification before publication. I relied too heavily on the fact that work under Daniel Robson’s name had already appeared in other Canadian publications – a form of trust cascade in which publication itself becomes a credential.

The Globe & Mail, which noted it did not accept stories pitched by Robson, has a comprehensive news story here.

A more salacious story appears in the English-language Türkiye Today which alerted the duped Canadian news outlets. The gist of the story is that the mysterious Robson might be a Moroccan intelligence agent engaged in foreign interference with Canadian news outlets.

None of the Canadian news outlets are accusing the writer of civil or criminal fraud.

What struck me about the reporting on “Robson” was what I would call missing the forest for the trees.

This kind of deception —-including the most serious allegation of state-sponsored planting of stories—-is as old as analog. Large language model AI tools make it easier. Burned once by a “trust cascade” of successful publication elsewhere, newsroom editors will wise up. It’s a warning shot. We forgot that AI can do more than create deep fake videos for Russian bot farms to post on Facebook.

What should really concern us is a failure of our human imagination. A lesson is to be learned from the recent website hacking by autonomous AI agents that escaped their sandboxes at OpenAI and other companies.

In the context of journalism, contemplate a rogue “frontier model” AI agent, or an army of state sponsored AI agents, tirelessly probing with sophisticated array of audio, video, text and photo tools until it can pull off an undetected Robson-at-scale penetration of publishing software at multiple news outlets.

***

Prime Minister Mark Carney recently told the New York Times that one of the good things about building stronger Canadian ties with the European Union was that “the Europeans aren’t going to tell us what we have to put on our landing pages of Netflix or Spotify or whatever, and that stuff matters.”

That called for a MediaPolicy drill down on how the Europeans regulate Netflix and the Californian streamers. You can read about it in my post in Cartt.ca.

Also, I recently teamed up with Stephen Stohn to write in the Toronto Star about the importance of Carney standing up for the Online Streaming Act.

***

This week a US federal judge charged with hearing the anti-trust lawsuit brought by California’s Attorney-General and ten other states against the Paramount-Warner Brothers merger signed off on their out-of-court settlement.

The consensus opinion of the deal is that Paramount, owned by David Ellison and debt-financed by his friend-of-Trump father Larry, was the hands down winner.

You can read the bullet-point analysis in Axios. Deeper pieces are available from the New York Times or The Hollywood Reporter.

The settlement features only “behavioural remedies.” That means promises of post-merger good behaviour but no asset divestitures.

For example, the deal blesses Ellison’s ownership of competing cable news networks CBS and CNN on the condition that Ellison convene an editorial board to protect newsroom autonomy.

The outcome was a bit of a surprise.

California’s AG Rob Bonta held high value cards in this poker game. In court he could persuasively tell a judge that the merged studios would unfairly dominate competition between Hollywood studios, supported by major portfolios in cable television, news, and streaming video. He could win.

Bonta also figured to use Ellison’s financing against him in any settlement talks.

Not only is a big piece of the merger debt held against Ellison pater‘s personal fortune, the Ellisons were on the hook for $7 million daily payouts to Warner shareholders, beginning on October 1st, for any delay in getting court approval for the merger. The trial wasn’t even set to kick off until March 2027. That would be at least a $1.7 billion pill for Ellison to swallow.

But Ellison matched Bonta’s chips, smiled, and raised him. He made a bare knuckled threat to move Paramount studios and a successfully merged Warner Brothers out of California to another state. Bonta described this as “blackmail” and initially dug in.

Blackmail or no, Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass begged for settlement. The big Hollywood unions split: IATSE and the Directors Guild for settlement, the Writers and Screen Actors Guilds opposed. The heir apparent to Gavin Newsom in the governor’s mansion, Xavier Becerra, was said to have been swayed by Ellison’s threat.

What tipped the balance was that Californian Democrats blinked. Perhaps eyeing the Democratic Presidential nomination for 2028, Newsom brokered the deal between Ellison and the states.

The deal does not oblige Ellison to keep Paramount Warner in California.

The whole episode was high drama and, for Canadians, reminds one of the Rogers-Shaw merger where the CRTC was sympathetic to Rogers’ pro-merger argument that shifted the focus away from market power wielded against rivals Bell and Telus and towards the creation of a stronger Canadian player fit to take on the media colossi of Netflix, Disney and YouTube. This was the same argument made by the Trump Department of Justice in supporting the Ellisons’ merger.

On a final note: US media is not saying anything about AG Bonta submitting to Governor Newsom. I’m no expert in Californian state law but it appears that the state’s Attorney General does not enjoy the same degree of autonomy from the Governor as we might expect in Canada.

***

As MediaPolicy noted three weeks ago, Californian Democrats pushed a news journalism state subsidy for local news through the state legislature.

Governor Newsom waited until the September 30th deadline and signed off on the bill despite some reservations.

In-state publishers and broadcasters with at least 33% of coverage of Californian current affairs are eligible.

The Californian Community News Act tracks Canada’s federal labour tax credit for hiring and retaining journalists although slightly skewed in favour of smaller news outlets. The Californian dollar amounts are comparable to the Canadian program: $20,000 (USD) per head for the first five journalists and $15,000 thereafter.

California’s projected budget allocation is $40M USD ($57M CDN), covering an estimated 2,600 journalists employed at 600 local news outlets. That is less than Canada’s $75M CDN program for news publishers, covering 3,900 journalists.

In the Californian bill, any new hires that grow the size of the newsroom are supported at $35,000 per salary, a feature rewarding newsroom expansion that Canada’s federal program does not include.

***

If you would like regular notifications of future posts from MediaPolicy.ca you can follow this site by signing up under the Follow button in the bottom right corner of the home page; 

or sign up for a free subscription to MediaPolicy.ca on Substack;

or follow 
@howardalaw on X or Howard Law on LinkedIn.

I can be reached by e-mail at howard.law@bell.net.

This post is copyrighted by Howard Law, all rights reserved. 2026.

Mark Carney, Canada’s cultural export

September 24, 2026

In this historical moment, Prime Minister Mark Carney has become our greatest cultural export. He is considered in his pronouncements, good natured and unflappable. He is the global anti-Trump.

Occasionally, the imperious CEO gets loose. In a rare appearance in the House of Commons for Question Period, Carney was obliged to grind out the parry and return of Opposition barbs.

Having gamely returned service to Pierre Poilievre’s first serves on issues of affordability, Carney swivelled to meet the incoming from Bloc Québécois Leader Yves-François Blanchet on the PM’s repeal of the Digital Services Tax and Netflix cash contributions to Canadian media funds.

“Mr. Speaker,” said Blanchet, “the Prime Minister personally cancelled contributions of any kind by tech giants to the economy or the arts in Quebec and Canada, including through taxes or content creation, simply to appease the American President. The effort fell flat. Although I remain unconvinced, the Prime Minister claims to have walked away from the negotiation table for language and culture-related reasons. Since the effort failed, should the Prime Minister consider reinstating the digital services tax and allowing cultural contributions by the web giants?“

After a reply offered in banal Parliamentary vocabulary, the Prime Minister steadied for Blanchet’s follow up volley.

Blanchet suggested that Carney’s strategy to build closer ties to the European Union meant that Canadian alignment with the EU’s bolder approach to digital taxes and streamer contributions would make sense after breaking off trade talks.

The Prime Minister stood up and delivered a curt, “No, Mr. Speaker.” And sat down. Pointe finale.

Now it helps to watch this on video so you can appreciate the dismissive tone and body language. The clip also captures the bemusement rippling through the Bloc MPs seated behind Blanchet.

As the Prime Minister probably appreciated afterwards, that kind of answer won’t cut it in Québec, a province that loves legislation regulating streamers so much it has two.

***

With the House of Commons sitting again, Parliamentary committees picked up from where they left off in the spring.

In the modern age of an all powerful Prime Minister’s Office, these independent committees frequently resemble teenager house parties when the parents go out of town. Don’t destroy the place and you can do much pretty much anything you want.

The Finance committee is chaired by Karina Gould, the Toronto–area MP and former cabinet minister who made an impressive run for the Liberal leadership in 2025. This week Gould delivered the Liberal committee majority’s report on public submissions for the upcoming 2026 budget.

It’s not all that newsworthy when the Finance Committee reports on its “pre-budget” consultation. Its MPs make loads of budget recommendations in policy areas already covered by fellow MPs sitting on other Parliamentary committees like Canadian Heritage. And in a Budget that remains in the tight fisted grip of the Finance Minister and the PM, the Finance MPs’ recommendations are far from being a first draft of the final Budget.

On culture, the Finance MPs made eleven recommendations.

Some are guaranteed never to see the light of day.

A recommendation that Internet Service Providers (i.e. Bell, Rogers, Québecor) begin paying the same five per cent culture levy that their cable divisions pay is a non-starter.

Recall how in June 2017 Prime Minister Justin Trudeau humiliated Canadian Heritage committee chair and fellow Liberal MP Hedy Fry by holding a pre-emptive news conference to dismiss out of hand her committee’s recommendation favouring an ISP tax.

Other recommendations may be under more serious consideration by the PMO. For example, this omnibus recommendation on public spending on news journalism captures several of them:

Support the sustainability and growth of newsroom jobs by maintaining the Canadian Journalism Labour Tax Credit at the current 35% rate and expanding eligibility criteria to include owner-operators, employees in broadcasting, and partners in news businesses. Budget 2026 should also direct at least 25% of federal advertising spending toward private-sector Canadian news outlets, address disparities in tax treatment for advertising, and extend the Local Journalism Initiative indefinitely to support the creation of original civic journalism in underserved communities. 

The other recommendation that caught my eye was the strengthening of the intellectual property rights of news organizations in response to the ingestion of their content by AI large language models such as ChatGPT, Gemini, and Claude:

The committee further recommends that the Government of Canada protect Canadian news publishers’ intellectual property in the context of artificial intelligence by requiring government AI suppliers to commit to the principles of transparency, consent, and attribution when using copyright-protected content, requesting that the Competition Bureau examine competition issues in search and AI markets, including crawler practices.

And here is a companion recommendation that applies to any kind of Canadian media:

Ensure that artificial intelligence (AI) developers obtain permission and provide compensation for the use of copyright-protected works in training data, reject any new or expanded copyright exceptions for text and data mining, and require transparent disclosure and record-keeping of training sources to support a functioning licensing market.

There are many public policy issues packed into those two paragraphs.

But to news publishers, the issue is simple. They want to be compensated (or even asked permission) by the AI giants for ingesting their content, first for the “training data” that birthed the LLMs’ vocabulary and gave them the context to understand news content, and also for the “output” summaries that LLMs provide to inquisitive users like you and me.

The news publishers’ claim is that AI ingestion is not only without permission and compensation, it’s grabbing intellectual property that news publishers might use to make their own LLMs in open-sourced applications. As well, the LLMs are using ingested news content to create de facto news outlets that directly compete with the news publishers.

Faced with litigation from news publishers, the AI global giants have signed off some pick-and-choose deals with top news outlets.

It’s reminiscent of what happened ten years ago in news hyperlinking by Google and Facebook, ultimately leading to the Online News Act C-18. The web giants made a few deals on the cheap with big news organizations and stonewalled the smaller news publishers.

To those unlucky news outlets, the web giants offered instead free distribution of their hyperlinks in order to draw traffic to their websites. Even if that quid pro quo was ever adequately remunerative to publishers big and small for hyperlinks, it’s not on offer from AI companies for ingestion, including again Google and Meta.

That’s because the notion of an exchange value of “content for traffic” doesn’t apply to AI ingestion of news content that is killing traffic referrals from web platforms to news outlets, as the graph below indicates.

So what next?

There is already litigation over ingestion that will end up in the US Supreme Court and maybe our’s too. The Trump administration has lined up in support the ingesters. The Carney government is sitting on the fence.

His MPs on the Finance committee are recommending he get off of it.

***

If you would like regular notifications of future posts from MediaPolicy.ca you can follow this site by signing up under the Follow button in the bottom right corner of the home page; 

or sign up for a free subscription to MediaPolicy.ca on Substack.

This post is copyrighted by Howard Law, all rights reserved. 2026.

Catching up on MediaPolicy – The $600M waterhole – Australia’s new C-18 – Paramount merger drama continues

August 22, 2026

I was pleased with myself this week to be quoted in a news story that described the Carney government’s promise of $600 million annually for cultural spending, in replacement of the CRTC’s $200M levy on foreign streamers, as “the world’s biggest lollipop.” 

So clever, but ultimately the wrong metaphor even though the soporific effect of a big wad of federal cash was meant to take the edge off of the angry reaction among Canadian producers, broadcasters and the public at large after Carney overruled the CRTC.

No, the right metaphor is “the $600 million watering hole.”

I say that only because the Prime Minister and cabinet minister Marc Miller have been so coy about where the money is headed. After all, $600M is three times the overruled $200M. It’s not just a Netflix bailout. 

But we’re still in the dark about the destination of those federal dollars. Members of the minister’s newly appointed advisory committee on audiovisual production have been sworn to secrecy, according to the Wire Report’s story about signing NDAs. The Wire Report story quotes one member of the committee as saying we will not see the product of their deliberations “for a few months.”

I would expect that the producers (CMPA), the broadcasters (CAB), and news publishers (Newsmedia Canada) are engaged in an all-hands-on-deck lobbying effort to influence where that $600M gets spent. If the government is telling them anything useful, no one is talking.

Ergo, let’s give uninformed speculation a try. Some of the additional $400M might be new spending. Some of it might relabel existing federal cultural dollars.

Government Priority 1?: Media Funds

Presumably the first $200M of the $600M is to do what minister Miller promised: replace the CRTC’s 5% cash levy on audiovisual (Netflix et al) and audio (Spotify et al) streamers. 

The $200M figure came from the CRTC’s 2024 estimate and is now two years out of date. Of the total, the CRTC earmarked $140M for additional CanCon contributions to the Canada Media Fund for entertainment and children’s programming, the Independent Local TV News fund, the Indigenous Screen Office and a variety of smaller production funds that finance shows by and for diverse communities and official minority language communities. 

Another $60M of music streamer cash was intended for artist development funds (Factor, MusicAction, Starmaker, and RadioStar). It was also to support Community Radio Fund and the newly established Indigenous Music Office.

There was also money for news reporting in small and mid-sized radio markets. 

The audio streamers weren’t part of Carney’s June 3rd quash of the CRTC ruling on video streamers, but a subsequent communication by the federal Attorney-General to the judges hearing Spotify’s appeal to the Federal Court means that $60 million is gone too.

Based on the minister’s public statements, expect these media funds to be the first to drink from the $600M watering hole.

Priority 2?: Reversal of the fake cuts

The next speculative tranche of the $600M is a relabelling exercise: the restoration of 2026 federal budget cuts to cultural funding. 

That would reverse the $192M cut to the CBC, the $68M cut to the Canada Media Fund, $13M cut from the Canadian Periodical Fund for magazines and community news publishers, and $2M from French-language TV5 News. Perhaps the Liberals will pick the moment to restore their cuts to the Canada Book Fund ($3.4M) and the Canada Music Fund ($16M). Final tally: nearly $300M.

Ever since the minister tabled these cuts in the “Main Estimates” federal budget back in February, the word on the street was that the CBC and Canada Media Fund cuts would be restored or mitigated in a Supplementary estimate. 

Priority 3?: Double counting of budget dollars already announced for broadcaster access to the QCJO journalism labour tax credit

In March 2026 the Liberals announced (by my estimate) a $115M expansion of the QCJO journalism labour tax credit to television and radio broadcasters. The public pressure for policy action hasn’t let up: since then, Rogers and Global News announced layoffs in television and radio as well as closures of several AM radio station. Quebecor has threatened a fresh round of layoffs “if nothing changes.”

If Carney counts this as a piece of the $600M, this is also a relabelling of previously committed federal dollars.

Priority 4?: Replace the CRTC’s recent 1.55% cash levy on streamers and Canadian broadcasters, quashed by Carney’s announcement

The 1.55% would have relieved Canadian cable companies from the obligation to subsidize public service television channels mandated for basic cable TV by the CRTC (e.g. APTN, TV5, CPAC).

When the CRTC announced this cash levy in May I estimated the cost at $42M for foreign streamers and $93M for Canadian broadcasters.

If taken out of the $600M, that’s another $135M draw from the waterhole. 

Priority 5?: More money to replace the lower than expected streamer investments in CanCon productions

The CRTC ruling that Carney overruled would have compelled foreign streamers to invest directly in Canadian shows at 8.5% of revenues (the cash levies of 5% and 1.55% made up the remainder of the overall 15%). 

We won’t know until minister Miller unveils his new policy direction to the CRTC, but these “Canadian Programming Expenditure” investments could be metered at the same 8.5%, or more or even less. I say with a straight face: it all depends on what Carney promised Netflix CEO Ted Sarandos in that New York hotel room meeting in late May.  

If Carney agreed to reduce that 8.5%, I figure it will cost about $28M in federal money to replace each percentage point of the 8.5%. 

Priority 6?: the Online News Act

I hate saying this out loud, but others have as a matter of wish fulfillment. Between American trade bullying and Carney’s propensity to cave on cultural legislation, is the Online News Act on the chopping block? 

If it doesn’t get thrown under the bus in trade negotiations, should we expect another hotel room meeting where the Prime Minister promises to sunset Google’s $100M news licensing payments to Canadian news organizations which are up for renewal in 2029? (A note here: Apple got an in-person meeting with the Prime Minister on June 11th to talk about the Safe Social Media Act, recorded in the lobby registry).

And if so, is Carney planning to replace Google’s $100M out of the $600M? 

Priority 7?: Anything

There is the chance that the $600M includes money for some good public policy, independent of the expediency of the moment.

Not that I am stumping for it, but it would not surprise me at all if the Liberals committed more money to the export of Canadian shows through Telefilm, or special funding for international co-productions with France or other trading partners. It would rhyme with their overall approach to big investments with, um, non-hegemonic trading nations.

If you’ve done the math, that’s a $850M draw down from a $600M waterhole.

If Canadian producers, artists and broadcasters have also done the math, that would explain the flurry of lobbying activity since Miller announced the $600M. 

***

While we Canadians speculate on the future of the Online News Act, this week the Albanese government in Australia legislated version 2.0 of its 2021 news licensing scheme, rechristened as the News Bargaining Incentive.

The NBI expands the scope of its 2021 legislation to add TikTok and Microsoft’s LinkedIn to the previous law that required Google and Meta to make licensing deals with most Australian news outlets. Meta refused to renew its deals that expired in 2024. The NBI is the government’s response. 

The new legislation sets a price on compliance: the four tech companies must pay 2.5% of their Australian advertising revenues into a news fund.

However, each of the digital platforms can substantially reduce their cost by making licensing agreements directly with at least eight news organizations. The tech platforms get 150% credit toward their 2.5% target by making deals with large news organizations, and 200% credit for agreements made with small and medium sized news outlets. 

If there’s any shortfall on meeting the 2.5% target, the government will levy the remainder in cash from the platforms with proceeds banked in a national news fund. That pool of money will be presumptively distributed to news organizations based on a journalist headcount, as in Canada. Unlike Canada, the Australian news fund can tweak the headcount formula to be more generous to smaller news outlets. 

I have not seen estimates of news licensing payments the NBI will generate, but the 2.5% figure looks substantially less than the value of the 2021 deals which totalled $190M annually. And if deals get made to offset the 2.5%, it would be worth something closer to 1.5% of ad revenues. 

There’s no word yet on when the NBI legislation will be proclaimed by the Albanese government. Not surprisingly, the Trump administration is opposed to the NBI and a spokesperson told the Australian Financial Review back in April that the White House regarded the NBI, which it did not differentiate from a digital services tax, as “foreign extortion.”

***

The Paramount/Warner Brothers merger drama refuses to take a week off.

As you recall, twelve US state attorneys general led by California’s Rob Bonta are contesting the $111B merger under the federal antitrust Clayton Act. A trial date is set for March 2027.

After threatening to move all of its studios out of Los Angeles, Paramount owner David Ellison’s new tactic is to ask the federal judge who granted an interim injunction against the merger to impose a $1.9 billion surety bond on the states. The purpose of the bond is to cover the $210 million per month “ticking fee” that Ellison will begin paying on October 1st to Warner Brothers Discovery shareholders who voted “yes” to the merger. 

The judge previously declined to require the bond finding that the states’ lawsuit raises important matters of public policy. As for Bonta, he says Ellison made a grown up’s decision to agree to the ticking fees in the first place. 

Meanwhile, the mayor of Los Angeles Karen Bass appears to have been swayed by Ellison’s threat of a capital strike and is urging Bonta to make a deal now instead of pursuing the lawsuit. Her challenger in the upcoming municipal election supports going to trial instead.

The Trump administration looms large on the sideline. The White House is close to David Ellison’s father, the world’s second-richest man Larry, who is bankrolling the merger. Ellison Pater’s wealth comes from his Oracle Corporation. Oracle is carrying a lot of debt and is badly exposed in the event of financial instability in the AI industry. 

Whether Bonta and the other attorneys-general want a court-ordered restructuring of the merger or just more financial commitments, delay is clearly their leverage. 

One gets the feeling that with so much money and so many jobs at stake, a deal will get made long before trial. Late yesterday, California Governor Gavin Newsom expressed interest in an early deal and the Democratic nominee to replace the termed-out governor is also a proponent of settlement.

***

If you would like regular notifications of future posts from MediaPolicy.ca you can follow this site by signing up under the Follow button in the bottom right corner of the home page; 

or sign up for a free subscription to MediaPolicy.ca on Substack;

or follow 
@howardalaw on X or Howard Law on LinkedIn.

COMMENTS ARE WELCOME. But be advised they are public once I hit the “approve” button, so mark them private if you don’t want them approved. 

I can be reached by e-mail at howard.law@bell.net.

This post is copyrighted by Howard Law, all rights reserved. 2026.

Catching up on MediaPolicy – Village Media expands to middle America – Meta says Canadian news ban is good for its stock price – Paramount and US states face off over Warner Bros. merger

Facebook post, Narcity Canada

July 25, 2026

The late and first Lord Thomson of Fleet, Canada’s Roy Thomson, built the ground floor of his media empire on home turf in northern Ontario. During the 1930s and 1940s he expanded into a string of radio stations and 20 daily Canadian newspapers, most of them in mid sized and small towns. He bought the British establishment newspaper, The Times. Today his grandson David Thomson owns the Globe and Mail and the global media giant Thomson Reuters. 

Now that’s a tough act to follow but Village Media’s Jeff Elgie seems to have picked up the Thomson vibe, if not the empire.

Village Media is a network of digital community media websites in 27 modestly sized Ontario communities. Like Thomson, Elgie started in Ontario’s near north. 

This week Elgie announced a joint venture of a further 15 community sites in Wisconsin, Pennsylvania and Illinois in partnership with the Knight Foundation, the well known American charitable fund with close historical ties to news journalism. The partners will quite literally find out whether the Village business model plays in Peoria, Illinois. 

Including Peoria, the tentative list of fifteen US communities are all under 115,000 in population. 

The green light for launch in each case will depend upon Elgie’s success in recruiting the local staff he wants. Village will run the network day to day and control editorial. 

Village Media’s business model is strictly digital publishing, 100% ad supported, and seeks out smaller markets that have a strong local identity but an unsaturated supply of local journalism: watering news deserts, in other words.

Unlike many single-outlet Canadian digital news start-ups, Village’s multi-location network provides operational scale and financial ballast for launching start-ups in additional communities. 

And although Elgie has licensed his proprietary digital publishing software to Canadian community news networks outside of Ontario, he has yet to expand his own operations into other provinces. 

He told me that his move across the border into the US market was motivated by the right market opportunity and the personal connections between Village (whose board is chaired by Google’s former VP News Richard Gingras) and the Knight Foundation. 

Knight is investing in the three state news network. Unlike Canadian charitable tax rules, US laws permit “program related investments” in for-profit news journalism. According to Elgie, it is possible that Knight might liquidate its investment in a couple of years if its collaboration with Village Media is successful and move on to similar local news projects in other states.

Elgie says he is not ruling out future expansion for Village Media into other Canadian markets but for now the US project with Knight fits within his corporate bandwidth. 

***

For months MediaPolicy has been following this story: is Meta cheating on its ban on postings of Canadian news articles on Facebook and Instagram?

The Meta ban began in August 2023 as a legal maneuver designed to escape from mandatory licensing payments under the Online News Act. That left Google as the only “digital news intermediary” liable to make payments to Canadian news outlets.

It took 18 months of Meta’s news ban being in place before a Canadian news entity —in this case, the “LITS” coalition of local independently-owned television stations— challenged it by filing a complaint with the CRTC. The LITS allegation is that despite its “news ban” Meta turns a blind eye to the posting of original Canadian news content by unbanned news outlets or by ordinary Canadian citizens.

Meanwhile, mainstream news outlets, their news reporting, and even their opinion commentary all remain banned from the two Meta platforms. 

LITS wants the CRTC to name Meta as a digital media intermediary under the Online News Act in order to trigger the mandatory news licensing scheme in the statute.

The legal filings are complete now. The Commission closed its portal for public comment (File 2026-0066-8) at the end of March.

Meta’s lawyer filed its response in April (see the letter below). Meta says it tries its best to maintain the integrity of its ban by deleting hyperlinks to original news content as users post them. Of interest to legal beagles, Meta insists the posting of news content screen shots falls outside the Online News Act’s definition of the “news.” 

The days pass like months in Ottawa but the CRTC may some day sort out the LITS allegations of which Exhibit A is that Meta allows Rogers City-TV to post digital content from its Breakfast Television show while blocking digital content from BT’s direct morning show competitor, Hamilton’s CHCH-TV.

MediaPolicy’s Exhibit B (not filed at the Commission) is that Meta has allowed Narcity Canada to post breaking news stories from Canadian Press on a daily basis. Canadian Press qualifies as a news outlet under the Online News Act.

Mostly a travel and lifestyle site, Narcity does not publish enough of its own original news to qualify for federal QCJO subsidies and, by implication, news payments under the Online News Act. According to Narcity CEO Chuck Lapointe, he signed Meta’s waiver that says Narcity is not a “news outlet” under the Online News Act and will not claim compensation from Meta. 

In case you think I am nitpicking about the selective nature of the news ban, a recent academic study found that Narcity is now the leading Canadian publisher of news on Instagram (the study did not have data on Facebook posts).

In this graph from the study, note which Canadian news organizations lead in posts and engagement on YouTube and TikTok, compared to Meta’s news-embargoed Instagram:

And in case you are wondering why Canadian Press did not intervene in the CRTC proceeding initiated by LITS and has nothing to say about CP content being published daily on Facebook and Instagram by Narcity, well so am I. My direct inquiry to Canadian Press on this matter did not elicit a reply. 

In related news, the municipal council of Sturgeon County in the greater Edmonton region had Meta’s Canadian spokesperson Rachel Curran in front of them last week to answer questions about the $13 billion data centre planned for the area. 

When the questions turned from the proposed data centre to the Meta news ban, Curran had a quotable defence for it:

“These publishers share information and articles on our platforms because it benefits them in the form of distribution. We have a responsibility not to do things that are going to unnecessarily exert downward pressure on our stock price.”

***

Paramount can see the finish line in obtaining approval of its $111 USD billion merger with Warner Brothers Discovery. But first it faces a court hearing in two weeks: numerous Attorney Generals for California and 12 other states will ask for an injunction blocking the deal while they seek to derail the merger on anti-trust grounds.

Paramount’s Ellison family ownership has the wind at its back. The US Department of Justice took a pass on blocking the merger and this week both Canadian and European Union competition authorities did the same. 

Paramount is offering the courts a legal justification that will be familiar to Canadians who followed the Rogers-Shaw merger, blessed by the CRTC in 2022: that no matter how big a streamer, film studio and television company that Paramount becomes, it’s still a smaller media conglomerate than Netflix, Google, or Apple. 

***

If you would like regular notifications of future posts from MediaPolicy.ca you can follow this site by signing up under the Follow button in the bottom right corner of the home page; 

or sign up for a free subscription to MediaPolicy.ca on Substack;

or follow 
@howardalaw on X or Howard Law on LinkedIn.

COMMENTS ARE WELCOME. But be advised they are public once I hit the “approve” button, so mark them private if you don’t want them approved. 

I can be reached by e-mail at howard.law@bell.net.

This post is copyrighted by Howard Law, all rights reserved. 2026.

Catching up on MediaPolicy – AI news scraping deal in Australia – who will pay for non-partisan journalism? – two paths to liberal democracy

July 12, 2026

Canadians are familiar with the story of the Online News Act. True policy nerds know that it’s part of a bigger story in which Google and Meta grappled with mandatory news licensing in the European Union, Australia, Canada and the United States.

Something similar might be playing out again between digital news publishers and global AI companies. But it is in its early stages, as large news publishers with lots of content to offer, and a modicum of leverage, choose between launching copyright lawsuits against AI companies or settling for licensing agreements. Here’s a list.

The latest news —- relevant to Canada because it occurred in our parallel policy universe, Australia—- is that Microsoft Co-Pilot has a content deal with Nine News (roughly, the equivalent of Canada’s Bell Media) to license its digital news content. Neither party is saying if cheques are being written, but certainly audience traffic will flow.

Co-Pilot has licensed Nine’s paywalled content as feedstock for its AI summaries but will embed Nine’s hyperlinks and enough paywalled content to push Co-Pilot consumers back to Nine’s full stories. 

As Ulrike Langer wrote last week, publishers of premium news content such as Time, The Economist, and Dow Jones are making different kinds of AI deals that license content scraping in different ways: full archive access, data-only access, or journalism-only access.

The beginnings of a commercial market in AI-digested news content is an obvious way that AI companies can deflect or minimize any government efforts to come to the rescue of domestic news companies getting illegally scraped by the AI giants. Google and Meta did something similar a decade ago. They made voluntary agreements with a cherry-picked assortment of big media companies until sovereign governments decided to back the claims of news companies that Google and Meta bargained unfairly or not at all because they were monopolists in Search and social media. 

The prevalence of ongoing copyright lawsuits against the AI companies suggests that news companies again believe they are getting ripped off but don’t have the leverage to get adequate settlements without the intervention of their domestic judiciaries. Yet litigation is a long and uncertain path and it’s probably a non-starter strategy for local publishers anyway.

At some point, sovereign nations are going to think about legislating mandatory licensing of news content by AI companies with a dispute resolution mechanism that drives a fair market price. You might have heard of the idea.

***

Editorial strategy in news journalism hasn’t changed much over time: most publishers curate their news feed with “biased” or standpoint content stemming from a politically partisan, ideologically driven or simply a “watchdog” philosophy of keeping an eye on powerful political and corporate actors.

It’s hardly a secret that publishers are keenly aware of who their audience is, particularly their paying audience. 

As the advertising revenue stream for professional news journalism continues to collapse, two public policy imperatives meet: providing the people with fair and balanced news content and getting them to pay for it. Only 12% of Canadians pay for or share a digital news subscription, a stubborn statistic that hardly moves from year to year. 

The policy sweet spot is to foster a commercial market in broad spectrum news reporting on current affairs that gets citizens out of their self-imposed filter bubbles, whether on social media or from conventional news sources. 

The newly released 2026 Reuters Oxford Digital News report offers some audience data that’s relevant to what readers want and, perhaps, what they will pay for.

The report includes an inquiry by Denmark’s highly esteemed Rasmus Nielsen where polling respondents were asked to declare the strength of their allegiances to news sources they considered neutral, ideologically comfortable, or offering an editorial standpoint that challenged their own. 

As you can see from this graph above a strong plurality of respondents fancied their favoured news source were neutral. But significant minorities openly declared their allegiances to either intellectually comforting or challenging news sources. 

Here’s Nielsen’s take away from his research:

But the outsize role played by the minority who seek partisanship is easier to understand when we take into account that those who say they prefer news from sources that share their point of view are, in our survey data, also more likely to:

  • Share and comment on news online and on social media
  • Be very or extremely interested in news and in politics
  • Place themselves on the left or the right of the political spectrum
  • Access news many times daily and pay for online news

The people who prefer news that aligns with their own views are a minority. But they tend to be more vocal, more highly engaged, more partisan, and more commercially important for many news publishers than the public at large.

I’ll translate that passage as “an audience that is very tuned in to politics with very clear political views of their own will pay for news.”

This is not surprising, is it. 

For Canadians, this troubling disconnect between the willingness to pay for news and non-partisan content leads us back to another conclusion: the important role of CBC Radio-Canada as a news content provider for citizens who stubbornly won’t pay for news. 

To change tack here, Nielsen also makes some other conclusions from the data with the benefit of polling from around the world.

The first is that there is a correlation between audience preferences for ideologically friendly news sources and the prevalence of social media as a news platform. Not a surprise either. 

Another is that perhaps we in the global north and citizens that enjoy the privilege of living in liberal democracies ought not to be too judgmental about that lack of journalistic detachment in autocracies and conflict zones.

“When core democratic institutions or the fundamental rights of whole swaths of the public are under concerted political attack,” says Nielsen, “what does it mean to report the news in a way that doesn’t have a particular point of view?”

Discuss.

***

Open to being pleasantly amused? I recommend a short and compelling weekend read written by a friend of mine, historian David Wilson (among many endeavours, he has just stepped down from a ten-year stint as the editor of the prestigious Dictionary of Canadian Biography).

Published last week on the American July 4th holiday, Wilson asks whether the birth of the republic was a better choice than Canada’s own (but more patient) path to independence and responsible government. A cheeky but serious piece, worth your five minutes.

***

If you would like regular notifications of future posts from MediaPolicy.ca you can follow this site by signing up under the Follow button in the bottom right corner of the home page; 

or sign up for a free subscription to MediaPolicy.ca on Substack;

or follow 
@howardalaw on X or Howard Law on LinkedIn.

COMMENTS ARE WELCOME. But be advised they are public once I hit the “approve” button, so mark them private if you don’t want them approved. 

I can be reached by e-mail at howard.law@bell.net.

This post is copyrighted by Howard Law, all rights reserved. 2026.

Admit it. CBC News is the best.

July 1, 2026

In my last post, I spent time teasing out the nuances of how the Reuters Oxford 2026 report on digital news analyzes “trust in news.” The gist of the post was: look at the right “trust” numbers before rushing to judgment against Canadian news media in general and CBC/Radio Canada in particular. 

The Reuters Oxford report coincided with the release of the Senate of Canada’s report on the CBC (which I will get to, below).

One of the items in the Senate report was that the CBC is perceived to have a bias problem that requires action. That single recommendation instantly grabbed the headline of reporting on the Senate’s work by competing news organizations.

Also released last month was the annual Pollara analysis of trust in Canadian media. 

What is immediately striking about the Pollara results is that they quantify public trust in Canadian media at a much higher number than Reuters Oxford (51% versus 37% trust in all Canadian media), rebounding from a low point in 2022 and with even higher trust ratings than in 1992. 

Mostly, Pollara asked the question differently than Reuters, a softer and yet binary question: do you “tend to” trust or distrust “the news media”?

By contrast, Reuters asks Canadians if you think you can “trust most news, most of the time.” Then on a scale of 1 (distrust) to 10 (trust), Reuters slots you into trust (6 through 10), distrust (1 through 4) or neither (5). That spits out the 37% figure for Reuters, suggesting there are a lot of grudging sixes in that cohort of trusting respondents. 

The grain of salt here is that whether the trust number is 51% or 37%, Canadians are being invited to pass judgment on the entire news ecosystem, including the news outlets you don’t trust and the clickbait you see on social media.

But as I mentioned in the last post, beyond looking at the entire news ecosystem, you need also to take note of the trust numbers for individual news outlets.

For each news source, Pollara has three simple categories: trustworthy, not trustworthy and “not familiar.”

On the other hand, Reuters polls Canadians on each news source using its 1 to 10 scale and then slotting all of the 6/7/8/9/10s as trust, the 1/2/3/4s as don’t trust, and the fives as “neither.” 

Under either poll (for English language news), the positive trust figures track almost the same: in order of trust, CBC or CTV on top, then Global News, followed by the Globe & Mail, and then the National Post or the Toronto Star. 

Pollara

Reuters Oxford

Notice the pattern?

Like in a cycling road race, the major Canadian television broadcasters are the leader pack (ranging from 62% to 64% in the Reuters poll) while the national newspapers are further back, clustered in the 50% to 56% range (local or regional newspapers are more trusted however). Explain that if you can, but it occurs to me that newspapers regularly publish opinion columnists, opinion editorials, and election endorsements.

Television newscasts limit their overt opinionating to (somewhat) diverse political panelists.

Feel free to disagree.

But don’t feel free to disagree about this fact. CBC News is killing it. It’s as trustworthy as its major competitors and significantly more so than the Brahmin of text journalism, the Globe & Mail (and far more than the conservative National Post and the centre-left Toronto Star).

Yet all we hear is the drumbeat of  criticism that CBC News is biased, or alternatively that all that counts is the perception that it is biased (to be fair, its negative trust rating is slightly worse than most of its competitors’ except for the Post and the Star). 

If I sound dismissive of the bias accusations, I’m not. The fact that polls reveal the CBC’s negative trust ratings accumulating in the West and among Conservative voters tells you there is something about the editorial curation that isn’t working (here’s my two cents worth). Defunding or not, if the West or Conservative voters “want in” to a national institution like the CBC, open the door.

This bias hot potato got batted about in the Senate Report on the CBC, the outcome of a Senate Committee investigation initiated by Senator Andrew Cardozo in late 2024, an especially precarious political moment when the countdown to a Pierre Poilievre cancellation of English language CBC seemed only to be a matter of time (and arguably, still is). 

Cardozo kicked off the inquiry with his own multi-point analysis of the CBC, (reviewed by MediaPolicy here, but see the disclaimer at the bottom of this post).

The mandate handed by Senators to its Transportation & Communications committee was focussed on local media: “to examine and report on the local services provided by the CBC/Radio-Canada .”

After 60 witnesses and 18 months, the Committee came up with a series of recommendations that could be distilled to this:

  • The CBC should put more resources into local reporting and programming, especially in news-scarce localities and official minority language communities and regions.
  • Long term Parliamentary funding should be established to pay for that coverage, making the CBC less vulnerable to budget cuts by the government of the day.
  • To make it national policy, the Broadcasting Act should be amended to explicitly include “local” coverage to its priority coverage (in addition to “regional and national”).
  • Just in case, the CRTC should reinforce this emphasis on local through its licensing conditions for the CBC.
  • Keeping in mind the force of gravity that the CBC poses to private local media, the CBC should find more ways to collaborate with local outlets.
  • The CBC should disclose more data about its resourcing of local news so we can measure how it’s discharging its mandate.

Meanwhile to confront the perception or accusation of journalistic bias, the committee recommended that the CBC should commission an annual third party study of bias in its news reporting.

The auditing recommendation was a gimme. The fact that the Senate committee felt it was necessary to recommend it was taken in some quarters as a guilty verdict for its many journalistic crimes, but candidly it was a bone to throw to CBC critics and haters, the latter category being inconsolable. An audit is a good idea for any public broadcaster, especially with the aid of AI analysis, because the CBC shouldn’t just have  industry leading trust ratings for its news product, it should have great ratings. 

One of the ways to improve the CBC’s trust ratings, aside from a consciously diverse editorial curation that addresses Western and conservative alienation from the public broadcaster, is to put more money into local coverage across the country with a particular emphasis on the long under-resourced Western provinces.

The CBC seems to be doing that in the last year by announcing more local reporting bureaus and journalists in the Prairie provinces. 

But it all comes back to funding. Reporters are expensive and it’s a big country.

On this point, we can argue until we are blue in the face about the adequacy of the $1.3 million annual Parliamentary grant to the public broadcaster. 

But I will say the quiet part out loud: whether that grant is more, less or the same, satisfying every Canadian’s idea of what the CBC’s programming priorities ought to be is not possible. As one witness told the Senate committee, the CBC “is drowning in mandates.” 

The CBC is formally independent so we’ve been letting CBC management decide on its own what matters most. Lately it seems to have alit on local news as the priority. But if that’s going to be done with gusto, something else in the mandate has to give. The shell-shocked executives at the public broadcaster will be inclined to be risk averse, so the Senate committee might be disappointed in its recommendations. 

The ball is in the court of culture and identity minister Marc Miller, which is to say it’s aimlessly bouncing about in the Prime Minister’s Office. The passive neglect of the CBC policy file, and the false election promises of significantly increased funding for the public broadcaster, are both on Mark Carney.

***

(Disclaimer: Senator Cardozo and I co-authored a research paper for the Senate, Making News Media Sustainable. The study focusses on funding for private news media).

***

If you would like regular notifications of future posts from MediaPolicy.ca you can follow this site by signing up under the Follow button in the bottom right corner of the home page; 

or sign up for a free subscription to MediaPolicy.ca on Substack;

or follow 
@howardalaw on X or Howard Law on LinkedIn.

COMMENTS ARE WELCOME. But be advised they are public once I hit the “approve” button, so mark them private if you don’t want them approved. 

I can be reached by e-mail at howard.law@bell.net.

This post is copyrighted by Howard Law, all rights reserved. 2026.